Here goes:
Mod: phantom - Need I say more? It's a close race between playing with him and having him mod, though...
Wolves:
Myself - If I could pick for myself a role this would be it. Ever since the first game *refuses to go off on a tangent* I've wanted to have another shot at this role. I can't say how good I'd be at it, but if voting records are any kind of indication I could last quite a while - apparently I'm not a terribly suspicious person, as I've never been lynched since WWI.
Fea - Fea has proven herself to be very good at this role, and besides, I'd rather have her on my side. For once I'd know what the heck she's playing at.
Besides, I think people have gotten to a point where they mostly suspect her for being her, rather than for reasons.
Oromin - She's a great quiet wolf to have around.
Seer: Boromir88 - now he'd be a powerful enemy. His performance in IIX was superb.
Ranger: Morm - he's a very astute player, I think he could play this role well. He may even make a save. (Am I the only one who's ever done that? I haven't paid much attention to the recent games.)
Hunter: Eomer - I think his performance in XII speaks for itself.
Cursed: Nilpaurion - I'd love to see him pull off that switch.
Others:
Saucepan - what's a game without SpM?
Fordim - I rather miss having him around. A great loudmouth, full of stretegies.
Kath - A game just doesn't seem quite complete without her.
Kitanna - Same as Kath. Another great backbone player
LMP - Another great player to have around...
TORE - If there was a cobbler, he'd be it, but otherwise a great player.
Esty - played brilliantly in XII.
Kuru - It's been too long since I've played in a game with him.
Gurthang - Another great player - and if I had a bear he'd be it.
There are definitely people I've left out here, sadly - I wish I could include about ten more. I also wish I knew more about some of the players who have only played in games IX and following, since I don't know anything about most of you except for some hearsay.