[Gurthang]

I've played Mafia, too.

The major differences are that in real life you can't go back and see votes or quote what was said. But at the same time, you can judge faces for sincerity or nervousness. I've acted as the moderator, or whatever you want to call it, and I thought it went pretty well. For me, at least, I made sure nobody talked during the night phase. The Mafia just pointed until they had agreed on someone to kill.

A big perk about the real game is that it goes so much faster. That's why I'd be willing to try Mith's idea.