The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIII: Enter Shamville

littlemanpoet · 11-07-2005, 03:27 AM

*LMP returns from coffin making and grave digging*

Nothing like a good flawed plan to ferret out some sense of relative innocence or perhaps guilt.

For toDay I am going to presume innocent, on the merits of their solid posts in response to my flawed plan:

Glirdan

Eonwe
Meneltarmacil
Firefoot
Kuruharan
Anguirel

Whereas Kuru's debunking of my plan came later than others, I'm taking into account his earlier posts in placing him amongst my presumed innocents. And even though Anguirels' post regarding my plan comes quite late, that he calls Menel's post a "sensible debunking" lends credence to his innocence as well.

Those whom I consider (at least) mildly suspicious are:

Kitanna
Bergil
tar ancalime

Bergil on the strength of his early vote, his reasoning for which has holes; yes, it's probably a random vote, so that's why I'm only mildly suspicious.

Kitanna's and tar ancalime's debunking of my flawed plan came rather late, such that they may merely be mimicking the attitudes of others, though their replies seem independently thought out. Still, they seem to be fence-sitting, and that is about as wolvish a behavior as I have yet seen. Since their posts could be construed either way, I'm still only mildly suspicious.

Which leaves:

Celuien
Kath
Lalaith
Waynethegoblin
Wilwa

Of these people, only Kath has said anything that I would consider of substance, namely 'morming'. I trust such an approach, but am aware that a werewolf might use it early in order to seem innocent.

Wilwa seems more playful than anything at this early stage.

Celuien and Lalaith have so far been posting in character, which tells me very little. Wayne's post was a mere "I'm here" post, and I have nothing to say about him.

Therefore, I'm watching those five for more indications, and keeping my eye on the three above-named 'mildly suspicious' individuals. My vote shall be for one amongst these eight. That's still too many to choose from, but there's still time.

And now it is time to process to the graveyard. Will you others assist in placing the dearly departed in the coffin? Thank you. And now ..... lift! Good, step slowly. On we go...

Edit: crossposted at this ungodly hour with Kath.

11-07-2005, 03:27 AM	#56
littlemanpoet Itinerant Songster Join Date: Jan 2002 Location: The Edge of Faerie Posts: 7,066	LMP returns from coffin making and grave digging Nothing like a good flawed plan to ferret out some sense of relative innocence or perhaps guilt. For toDay I am going to presume innocent, on the merits of their solid posts in response to my flawed plan: Glirdan Eonwe Meneltarmacil Firefoot Kuruharan Anguirel Whereas Kuru's debunking of my plan came later than others, I'm taking into account his earlier posts in placing him amongst my presumed innocents. And even though Anguirels' post regarding my plan comes quite late, that he calls Menel's post a "sensible debunking" lends credence to his innocence as well. Those whom I consider (at least) mildly suspicious are: Kitanna Bergil tar ancalime Bergil on the strength of his early vote, his reasoning for which has holes; yes, it's probably a random vote, so that's why I'm only mildly suspicious. Kitanna's and tar ancalime's debunking of my flawed plan came rather late, such that they may merely be mimicking the attitudes of others, though their replies seem independently thought out. Still, they seem to be fence-sitting, and that is about as wolvish a behavior as I have yet seen. Since their posts could be construed either way, I'm still only mildly suspicious. Which leaves: Celuien Kath Lalaith Waynethegoblin Wilwa Of these people, only Kath has said anything that I would consider of substance, namely 'morming'. I trust such an approach, but am aware that a werewolf might use it early in order to seem innocent. Wilwa seems more playful than anything at this early stage. Celuien and Lalaith have so far been posting in character, which tells me very little. Wayne's post was a mere "I'm here" post, and I have nothing to say about him. Therefore, I'm watching those five for more indications, and keeping my eye on the three above-named 'mildly suspicious' individuals. My vote shall be for one amongst these eight. That's still too many to choose from, but there's still time. And now it is time to process to the graveyard. Will you others assist in placing the dearly departed in the coffin? Thank you. And now ..... lift! Good, step slowly. On we go... Edit: crossposted at this ungodly hour with Kath.