The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XV-The Villagers Strike Back!

Meneltarmacil · 12-19-2005, 03:12 PM

Sorry, Boromir. I forgot you made those posts.

Anyhow, it is still likely that a Hero is in the list of those who voted for Nonnacedak. If the plan indeed was for the Heroes to split their votes, then Nonna would indeed be a good target for those who didn't vote for the biggest bandwagon around. Suspicion of Nonna had been voiced by many, and one vote would likely bring others. Consdier this: The plan would have been for two of the Heroes to join a bandwagon, or if a second bandwagon arose, to have each one join a separate bandwagon. The other would vote for Wayne, the silent one, in an attempt to have the vote split yet be able to give a good reason for it. And I do find it interesting that after suspicion of Nonna had been voiced by many and a vote already placed, our good Saucepan Huan votes for Nonna as well, creating another bandwagon for Heroes to hide in.

Boromir88, you may have accounted for yourself thus far, but if a Hero is hiding in that bandwagon, you still may be it. Kitanna was the first to openly vote for Nonna, something that it is wise for a Hero to avoid. I am not going to let her out of my sight, though, as a Hero can always double-bluff. Saucepan is dead and was not a Hero, and I feel, as before, that he was trying to get a bandwagon rolling. Spawn and Boromir88 are the best candidates for Hero #2. Trying to decide between them is difficult.

dancing spawn of ungoliant:
--Was somewhat quiet. Possibly trying to stay under the radar.
--Voted after Kitanna, but also after Rune cast the second vote for Wayne. Cross-posted with Saucepan, so she wouldn't have known that a second bandwagon was opening.
--Did not voice much suspicion of Nonna until the post right before she voted.

Boromir88:
--Louder than spawn
--First says "Kill Kath." Then he is in favor of killing either Nonna or Farael.
--Votes for Nonnacedak after 3 votes have sufficiently established Bandwagon #2. Would have voted according to plan.

If I'm right in that the Heroes split their votes, Boromir88 may well be Hero #2. Though Kitanna and spawn may also bear watching, particularly spawn.

Nevertheless, Rune son of Bjarne is probably getting my vote this time.

Edit: Some cross-posting, plus I put too much in bold.

12-19-2005, 03:12 PM	#4
Meneltarmacil Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: The bottom of the ocean, discussing philosophy with a giant squid Posts: 2,254	Sorry, Boromir. I forgot you made those posts. Anyhow, it is still likely that a Hero is in the list of those who voted for Nonnacedak. If the plan indeed was for the Heroes to split their votes, then Nonna would indeed be a good target for those who didn't vote for the biggest bandwagon around. Suspicion of Nonna had been voiced by many, and one vote would likely bring others. Consdier this: The plan would have been for two of the Heroes to join a bandwagon, or if a second bandwagon arose, to have each one join a separate bandwagon. The other would vote for Wayne, the silent one, in an attempt to have the vote split yet be able to give a good reason for it. And I do find it interesting that after suspicion of Nonna had been voiced by many and a vote already placed, our good Saucepan Huan votes for Nonna as well, creating another bandwagon for Heroes to hide in. Boromir88, you may have accounted for yourself thus far, but if a Hero is hiding in that bandwagon, you still may be it. Kitanna was the first to openly vote for Nonna, something that it is wise for a Hero to avoid. I am not going to let her out of my sight, though, as a Hero can always double-bluff. Saucepan is dead and was not a Hero, and I feel, as before, that he was trying to get a bandwagon rolling. Spawn and Boromir88 are the best candidates for Hero #2. Trying to decide between them is difficult. dancing spawn of ungoliant: --Was somewhat quiet. Possibly trying to stay under the radar. --Voted after Kitanna, but also after Rune cast the second vote for Wayne. Cross-posted with Saucepan, so she wouldn't have known that a second bandwagon was opening. --Did not voice much suspicion of Nonna until the post right before she voted. Boromir88: --Louder than spawn --First says "Kill Kath." Then he is in favor of killing either Nonna or Farael. --Votes for Nonnacedak after 3 votes have sufficiently established Bandwagon #2. Would have voted according to plan. If I'm right in that the Heroes split their votes, Boromir88 may well be Hero #2. Though Kitanna and spawn may also bear watching, particularly spawn. Nevertheless, Rune son of Bjarne is probably getting my vote this time. Edit: Some cross-posting, plus I put too much in bold. __________________ I ♣ baby seals.