[Farael]

Mithalwen, breath. I did not jump out of the blue saying I'm Carcharot, Gurthang made a comment saying that I was probably gifted and pretty much left me out in the open. Now I must say, I had no idea whom to hunt during the night. Menel was the one I suspected the most for some of the things he said and did. I was not as sold on his guilt as I made it sound, but I needed information and I wanted to start some kind of a reaction. Sadly, it was not what I expected.

I know who I am and therefore I know I'm innocent, I guess you all could have been swayed by Menel appearing as Sauron but now we know that he was not and are you going to tell me that his arguments made sense?

I gambled last night. I figured if I made a strong enough case that I'd hunt Menel then should the wolves want him dead, they'd get rid of me and possibly get two gifteds in one day. If neither Menel nor I had been killed then who among you can tell me that it would not be clear evidence against him?

Now that you know that Menel was indeed NOT Sauron, as I knew all along for he suspected me for more than one night, won't you listen to my words at least? you can get rid of me now and I won't have any good clues on who to hunt down with me. You know one innocent on me and maybe another in Mithalwen, but her saying that you guys MUST kill me tonight is starting to look suspicious.

You know you'll be dead Mithalwen? then help us. You are being just as destructive as I might have been. I never asked you to come out on the open, I even said that I did not expect other gifteds to say who they were, but I was flushed out by Gurthang and I felt I could risk admitting being Carcharoth so that we could get some things going. If you recall correctly, last night the top suspects were Nonnadeck (who now we know was innocent) and myself. I know I'm innocent so at least I tried to get something going.

I just want to make this very clear. I never said that Menel was as good as dead. I said that he was unless someone showed me I was wrong. Right away you jumped up and said you were Dragulin. Why? you could have argued your case in favour of Menel just as I argued mine against him. If you don't like my arguments I do not care, but I happened to have some. He is not the Seer, my arguments hold fairly true right now at least for suspecting him. But then, why would Mithalwen have any arguments in favour of Menel? Mithalwen voted for Menel the night before she says she protected him, if I'm not mistaken. I do not suspect Mithalwen right now because as Morm said when talking about me, it would only take the 'true' Dragulin (if there was another than her) to come out and she'd be as good as dead.

Sincerely, you called me stupid last night and I am quite offended by it, but is it any smarter what you did? Menel was not the Seer but even if he had been you could not protect him again. The Heroes wanted him dead but they can't control me or my thoughts. If they were all-but-certain that Menel was the Seer and they did not want to risk me changing my mind, they would have attacked him straight away. This which is what happened. As a bonus, now I look more suspicious. Hey, I challenge anyone who wants to claim to be Carcharoth to come forward!! There are only two heroes left and Sauron is still alive. If "another" Carcharoth shows up, then he must be a hero and therefore after the night only one hero will be left, Sauron would still be alive and with some luck, the game will be over before the moon sets tomorrow night.

Think of this as excuses and cover-ups if you may, but sooner or later you will see the truth. Let's hope for the former.


I hope I argued my innocence well enough, but I should start putting forward at least some ideas of who may be guilty.

Mormegil- Can't see him being too suspicious. He has cut back on his posting from the beginning but that's not evidence by itself. He was one of the last to vote for Nonna, making sure he'd be devoured but he said he was trying to avoid someone organizing a double-lynch. If he had been a Hero, wouldn't he want to get rid of possibly three innocents?

Gurthang- Many seem to suspect him, I'm not convinced yet.

Formendacil- Is it me or has he talked fairly little?

Farael-That's me, I'm obviously not suspecting myself

Lhuna- Timezones can be a killer, but she seems pretty innocent right now.

Eomer- I'm not going to comment right now, I'm still chewing my thoughts over.

Boromir- He is an intelligent wolf, which could mean he's a cunning hero, but I am not going to suspect him just yet

Spawn- I suspected her for being in the Nonnadeck bandwagon a couple nights ago, I'm still not sold on her innocense but I shall look elsewhere tonight.

Oddwen- She casted the last vote for Rune, if that doesn't clear her it surely brings her close to.

Kath-No comments... not yet at least.

Mithalwen- Ms. Dragulin... I'd love to see someone come up with a good claim at being the true Dragulin and get my paws on her, but it might just be the anger talking. I do not suspect her even though she does seem to hate me.

Wayne- He can get away with anything because "Wayne is Wayne" I don't know if we should devour him just yet.


A lot of posting has gone before I could wrap up my ideas. I hope I clarified why I admitted to be Carcharoth even if I am not the greatest threat of all the gifteds.

And Mithalwen, I did not know Menel was innocent, and you thought him Sauron so I believe you weren't any more correct than myself. I did not want to kill him only so that the heroes did not get to him first, I wanted to start controversy. Sadly, you commited yourself in a rather short-sighted way, but now you can't turn back.