The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XV-The Villagers Strike Back!

dancing spawn of ungoliant · 12-23-2005, 12:59 PM

Just to keep the statistics straight, here are last night's votes:

Menel -> Farael
Formendacil -> Nonnac
Nonnac -> Gurthang
Lhuna -> Gurthang
Farael -> Menel
Eomer -> Wayne
Gurthang -> Nonnac
Mith -> Farael
Boromir -> Nonnac
Wayne -> Farael
Kath -> Nonnac
Mormegil -> Nonnac
Spawn -> Nonnac

And now, my own ponderings:

Mith, I could to vote for Farael just to salute you for your excellent contribution to this community, but I can't do that because I still think that Farael is Carcharoth as he claims to be. If he wasn't, sure someone would already have stepped forth and said something. Then we had two Carcharoths and if we couldn't decide which one is lying, we'd arrange a double devouring and the real Carcharoth would kill the false one (ie. choose not to hunt, or then pick a third person to die with them).

I'm sure I'll be crudely insulted for saying this, but there are a few things that morm has done that make him look pretty suspicious right now. I'm very well aware that he was a cranky person before we knew that there were heroes among us, so I won't use that against him although it would be a nice cover for him.

But: I found (and still find) it strange that morm defended Nonnac before he had even posted and morm stood up for him every now and then ever since. Now, of course, we see that he was right about Nonna's innocence, but how did he know? Only the heroes know who are innocent and who are guilty from the beginning.

Another thing is his comment about me voting for Kitanna, which I already wondered in my post #193 . I was back then one of last Night's most unpopular villagers. His comment looked, at least to me, like he would have tried to get other people with him to get me back on the menu again that Night.

And now the double devouring idea of his which includes Wayne is a bit odd. If he thinks Wayne is a hero, won't one hero at a time be enough when the odds are that we'd take a regular wolf down with him - or even worse, our Seer - and the last hero would have one less innocent to worry about. If morm, however, thinks that Wayne is just annoying, he'd be eliminating an innocent vote and the heroes' chances to survive would grow better. Or am I just missing something?

edit: Oh, wow, you guys have turned a completely new page while I was writing... so, cross-posting once again

12-23-2005, 12:59 PM	#287
dancing spawn of ungoliant Mischievous Candle Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: So near to Russia, so far from Japan, quite a long way from Cairo, lots of miles from Vietnam. Posts: 1,234	Just to keep the statistics straight, here are last night's votes: Menel -> Farael Formendacil -> Nonnac Nonnac -> Gurthang Lhuna -> Gurthang Farael -> Menel Eomer -> Wayne Gurthang -> Nonnac Mith -> Farael Boromir -> Nonnac Wayne -> Farael Kath -> Nonnac Mormegil -> Nonnac Spawn -> Nonnac And now, my own ponderings: Mith, I could to vote for Farael just to salute you for your excellent contribution to this community, but I can't do that because I still think that Farael is Carcharoth as he claims to be. If he wasn't, sure someone would already have stepped forth and said something. Then we had two Carcharoths and if we couldn't decide which one is lying, we'd arrange a double devouring and the real Carcharoth would kill the false one (ie. choose not to hunt, or then pick a third person to die with them). I'm sure I'll be crudely insulted for saying this, but there are a few things that morm has done that make him look pretty suspicious right now. I'm very well aware that he was a cranky person before we knew that there were heroes among us, so I won't use that against him although it would be a nice cover for him. But: I found (and still find) it strange that morm defended Nonnac before he had even posted and morm stood up for him every now and then ever since. Now, of course, we see that he was right about Nonna's innocence, but how did he know? Only the heroes know who are innocent and who are guilty from the beginning. Another thing is his comment about me voting for Kitanna, which I already wondered in my post #193 . I was back then one of last Night's most unpopular villagers. His comment looked, at least to me, like he would have tried to get other people with him to get me back on the menu again that Night. And now the double devouring idea of his which includes Wayne is a bit odd. If he thinks Wayne is a hero, won't one hero at a time be enough when the odds are that we'd take a regular wolf down with him - or even worse, our Seer - and the last hero would have one less innocent to worry about. If morm, however, thinks that Wayne is just annoying, he'd be eliminating an innocent vote and the heroes' chances to survive would grow better. Or am I just missing something? edit: Oh, wow, you guys have turned a completely new page while I was writing... so, cross-posting once again __________________ Fenris Wolf Last edited by dancing spawn of ungoliant; 12-23-2005 at 01:02 PM.