It is a wonderful article there Elladan and I can see the point being argued.
I mean if we consider it in Faramir's mind, why let go two people who have been lying and trying to squirm their way out of a capture? There is a major difference between their interactions, Frodo in the books is very upfront and straight. They still conceal things, but they still remain truthful, declaring it as an "Oath taken at the Council of Elrond." Despite this, they are straight and upfront with Faramir in the books. Movies there's a clear difference between their interactions.
__________________
Fenris Penguin
|