The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVI: No man is an Island

Cailín · 01-17-2006, 04:28 PM

Well, I had expected this. Poor Gurthang. Lhuna, what can you tell us? I fear it is not much...

I was rather suspicious of TGWBS the previous days, but ultimately got this nagging feeling he might be an innocent after all. I was not surprised, though very disappointed of course when it turned out he indeed was an Ordo.

I’m too sleepy to make much sense, so I shall just list names again.

Proven Innocents:

Alcarillo
Lhunardawen
Naria

Likely Innocent But Also Likely Not (and how ironic if among these are in fact our wolves):

Azaelia
Farael
Rune

Those Who Are Probably Going To Argue One Another To Death toDay:

Kuruharan
Meneltarmacil
Amanaduial
Malkatoj
Cailín (I suppose I go into this category myself)

Among those who are left, there are still two other Gifteds!

I would ask any of our Gifteds, even though this might sound illogical, to reveal themselves IF and only IF they are likely going to be lynched toDay. And that is not when Amanaduial mentions you in one of her jumpy posts or when Malkatoj expresses one of her bad feelings, or if someone random votes for you, but if you are in real, actual danger. We cannot risk losing you and if your claim is fought, we have found ourselves a wolf!

I could agree with lynching anyone in the last category (excepting me of course, I am not yet as suicidal as some Ordos were) but possibly also in category two if someone comes up with an excellent theory (and then I am of course inclined to trust our three proven innocents more, though anyone could be wrong).

I will analyse tomorrow and see if I can come up with anything at all, though I must admit I feel as much at loss as yesterday. I was so convinced of Naria’s guilt, I shall have to come up with an entirely new theory.

01-17-2006, 04:28 PM	#366
Cailín Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Lurking in the shadows. Posts: 711	Well, I had expected this. Poor Gurthang. Lhuna, what can you tell us? I fear it is not much... I was rather suspicious of TGWBS the previous days, but ultimately got this nagging feeling he might be an innocent after all. I was not surprised, though very disappointed of course when it turned out he indeed was an Ordo. I’m too sleepy to make much sense, so I shall just list names again. Proven Innocents: Alcarillo Lhunardawen Naria Likely Innocent But Also Likely Not (and how ironic if among these are in fact our wolves): Azaelia Farael Rune Those Who Are Probably Going To Argue One Another To Death toDay: Kuruharan Meneltarmacil Amanaduial Malkatoj Cailín (I suppose I go into this category myself) Among those who are left, there are still two other Gifteds! I would ask any of our Gifteds, even though this might sound illogical, to reveal themselves IF and only IF they are likely going to be lynched toDay. And that is not when Amanaduial mentions you in one of her jumpy posts or when Malkatoj expresses one of her bad feelings, or if someone random votes for you, but if you are in real, actual danger. We cannot risk losing you and if your claim is fought, we have found ourselves a wolf! I could agree with lynching anyone in the last category (excepting me of course, I am not yet as suicidal as some Ordos were) but possibly also in category two if someone comes up with an excellent theory (and then I am of course inclined to trust our three proven innocents more, though anyone could be wrong). I will analyse tomorrow and see if I can come up with anything at all, though I must admit I feel as much at loss as yesterday. I was so convinced of Naria’s guilt, I shall have to come up with an entirely new theory.