[Kath]

Wow this is not good. Shelob dead yesterday and now Fea and tar as our gifted's! With the first a needless death we are not doing well.

Mith to answer your concerns I was reading the thread backwards when working out who had voted, and there was probably no order in particular to the lists as I don't often think about that, I just find the names and stick them in.

Now, unless Garin comes up with one hell of a reason not to vote for him today that's where I'll be headed with mine. Arguing with him about Shelob last night, well, the second she voted for herself it was obvious she was not a wolf, and he kept on and on at her, and then tried to include me in his arguments! The whole time looking for support from Ang, though if Garin turns out to be a wolf I would be inclined to think that Ang isn't and that it was an attempt to ally himself with an innocent. I realise that there were others (including myself) who voted for Shelob, but Garin was there while all the arguing was going on. Perhaps it was just that he didn't see how stupid it would be to be a bluffing wolf at that point, but somehow I don't think he's that dense.

Anyway, there's fair warning to you Garin. Get defending.