View Single Post
Old 02-04-2006, 03:13 PM   #70
Kath
Everlasting Whiteness
 
Kath's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Perusing the laminated book of dreams
Posts: 4,533
Kath is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.Kath is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.Kath is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.
Send a message via MSN to Kath
Aiwendil, why are you so concerned that we add no more people to list of those with votes? Yes there is a chance that one of the wolves is in there, but it is good to spread the votes rather than bandwagon, because the latter means that anyone who got involved in one is pretty much automatically suspected over the next few Days.

Ok, I have a while, let's do the boring bit:
morm:
Wonders if Gil is the Cobbler and is trying to make people concentrate on him so the wolves are ignored. (Fair point but Gil often complains about the fact that he dies early, I should say it was more of the same rather than any plan.)
Realises that Form is doing something similar, but decides he is innocent. (Odd because via the same reasoning he gets two different views.)
Changes view of Gil, now thinking him just a confusing innocent. (Sudden swerve there.)
Some suspicion of malka, though I suspect that was done in jest.
Suspicious of malka and Cailin for their desire to kill Gil or Wayne (the latter later refuted this claim) and then mentions that he would be for killing those innocents that don't contribute a great deal, which would include Wayne. (A bit contradictory as well as mistaken.)
Votes for Valier 'because of the giggling' and to stir things up. (Never mentioned her by name before but considers her useless to the village on basis of occupation.)
Later claims this is not based on role but rather because those with roles of a useful nature are more likely to be useful to the village. (Still seems based on role to me.)

Garin:
Did an analysis based on occupations. More suspected than given benefit of the doubt. (Whole post was pretty pointless as those were chosen before roles were given out).
Inclined to vote for Marcolie because she's not spoken yet.
Not keen on morm because his ideas are so bleak, yet admits his ideas are the same. (Very odd, contradictory and insulting.)
Feels that SpM is innocent 'because he always is'. (Dangerous reasoning.)
Thinks roles may be a good cover for wolvishness and will vote for Crombie or Valier, presumably based on theirs. (Again, occupations chosen before roles announced.)
Flipped a coin and voted for Valier, even though he wants to vote for Crombie.

Nilp:
Fake argument between 3 wolves followed by a vote for himself. (Usual tactics.)
Asks the village not to vote for spawn. (But we know why that is )

spawn:
Analyses everyone.
Looks at the pros and cons of lynching Wayne, Gil or Valier.
Shows that Crombie has been flipflopping around between suspicions, wonders if she is perhaps the Cobbler, but thinks she is too smart to show herself up like that. (Valid points, though the role could be freaking Crombie out and making her act out of character.)
Votes Crombie, seemingly in order to cause a double lynch! (Very odd, why do that by choice? Although, perhaps in the hope that we will see the hand of a wolf in breaking it one way or the other.)

And now I'm out of time, that look longer than anticipated. If still alive tomorrow I'll continue. As far as I've got it is spawn that seems to stand out as innocent, so I'm going to accept her ideas about Crombie. I've not seen anyone I've really wanted to vote for toDay, but those points about her flipflopping around are persuasive.

++ABERCROMBIE OF ROHAN

And goodbye.
__________________
“If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.”
Kath is offline   Reply With Quote