As promised, I did some research of the quieter ones, and came up with analysis of
Naria and
malkatoj (although the latter has been pretty vocal).
Day 1:
Naria weeps the loss of Meneltarmacil and says that the Day 1 is rather random, and that's about all we get out of her. She promises to make a post later with a vote, though. Indeed, at the end of the Day we get 21 words forming an apology for lateness and a vote for
Nilp (and it's a reasoned vote, too: "Too crazzzy!!").
Day 2:
*silence*
Day 3:
Naria says she had a perfectly good excuse for not posting. Fair enough. She also says that she was fairly quiet in her last game, three posts a day at tops (I'm not sure why she's telling this... does it mean that once you are a silent villager, you'll always be a silent villager?)
"I will not analyse anyone for there is enough people doing a good enough job already." ~Naria
Apparently it wasn't good enough since we haven't caught a wolf yet. In any case, that's a really weird thing to say. Did she know that we were way off of the real culprits and she thought she'd sit back watching us 'barking up the wrong tree' as we were already doing it so well? Why does she refuse to share her thoughts?
"I will however post a personal thought about each player later on." ~Naria
I'm still waiting for that post to come.
Naria thinks the idea of a double lynching sounds wolvish. She says that if a double lynching happens, then it happens but it shouldn't be planned. I disagree with this. I think accidental double lynchings don't really serve the purpose. A wolf can hide behind an "accident" and if we decrease our numbers twice the amount as usually in one Day, it should be discussed together.
Naria explains why she's quiet. She says she trusts her gut feelings since she's not good at reading between the lines. Her post #206, doesn't look that suspicious to me although I'm not sure when she said that "I do think that he [
Formendacil] is acting Cobblerish and I would like to think that someone would agree with me on this."
She has just said that she wants to keep her own mind about voting, but the she wishes to get some support. I don't know... All in all Naria seems quite suspicious to me now and I'd really like her to post more her thoughts even if they are gut feelings.
***
Day 1:
Malkatoj is eager to get rid of
Wayne and
Gil.
"I think our best bet today would be to lynch either Gil or Wayne. Though we can't know if they're wolves, they are distracting and it'd be better to have them out of the way before we get to a point where there's real evidence." ~malkatoj
The next thing she says is that she's almost sure that Wayne is just being Wayne, though. Later she votes for Wayne for the reasons she explained earlier.
Day 2:
"I'm also inclined to think, like Wayne and Gil, it's just Garin being Garin--in the last game he acted in this manner as well." ~malkatoj
She suggests the good old 'wolves are in the bandwagon' theory although points out
Shelob's safe vote (why only Shelob?). She says she meant
Kath with her vote for
Aiwendil and although some people would seem to think her as innocent after this, I'm not so sure.
Day 3:
Malkatoj is irritated because Wayne is still alive (although she has said all the time that he's probably innocent). She says that
Sauce started both
Shelob and
Abercrombie bandwagons.
"Even if you don't vote for him [Sauce], don't vote with him--innocent or no, it's dangerous to let one person have so much power over us." ~malkatoj
Wow. That's quite a statement: Do not listen to The Saucepan Man. Nice piece of propaganda there. Malkatoj wants both Sauce and Wayne dead, but is uncertain, what to do. Asks a public opinion of double lynching and says she'd like to have it.
She votes for Sauce "for getting us to kill our innocent friends twice in a row".
Now, both ladies are looking rather suspicious to me and so do their votes. It's probably a safest vote ever to cast it for someone who already has votes, but who's not going to get lynched that Day.
On Day 1, malkatoj voted for Wayne giving him a third vote when
Valier already had three and Abercrombie had 5. Naria, for one, gave Nilp a third vote just at the end of the Day.
I think I will probably vote for either of them toDay.