|
Naria, Marco, Gil - "The Quiet Three"
Both Naria and Marco have only posted six times, at the moment of writing. Both have been silent and sweeping under the radar, so to speak.
Naria
Post 1 - says little.
Post 2 - Votes for Nilp as he is crazy.
Fair enough under normal circumstances, but what was the point? A vote for Valier or Wayne - with 3 each - would have had more chance of determining the outcome than a throwaway vote for Nilp. Or even a vote for Abercrombie, if you suspected her. Three perfectly good options, but instead she throws her vote away.
Post 3 - As has already been said, she says she will post a comment of each villager later but then fails to do so. She also claims others are doing a good enough job of analysis - a very dangerous view, because all other analyses are potentially undertaken by wolves. She claims she has been quiet due to computer problems.
Post 4 - Says she doesn't like double lynchings. Seems logical enough, no need to do the wolves work for them unless we are pretty certain of our candidates.
Post 5 - Again, asks for forgiveness on the basis of computer problems. She also claims she goes through all posts to see what people are saying, and claims she is not good at reading between the lines. Again, this shows a dangerous willingness to accept other people's words at face value.
She then says she will make her own decisions - but using her gut instead of her head. Why anybody would prefer the use of an organ usually destined to processing ones meals over one's brain is beyond me.
She votes Form. A reasonably safe vote, but one with the potential to not be.
Last post - Says there was a storm. Posts her views on everybody, then leaves.
In conclusion, her silence seems to have been accounted for a lot better than others. However, it is the useless votes that incriminate. Her unwillingness to form her own ideas is also very worrying. So I agree, one to watch.
Marcolie
Day 1 - nothing
Post 1 - Says computer was broken. Vaguely believes in wayne, Gil, Valier and Glirdan's guilt.
Post 2 - Suspects Cailin for this ridiculous notion of "thought steering."
Suspects SpM because of "strength at playing." Eh?!
Thinks Glirdan is innocent.
Advocates voting for Gil, wayne, Valier or Naria based on their quietness. Er... a little rich.
Says she suspects Garin, similarly to morm "don't know exactly why."
Post 3 - Says she had the opportunity to vote, but can see no reason why she didn't. Doesn't try to defend himself on this. Seems a bit odd.
Posr 4 - Votes for wayne, with little choice, obviously. Says there's a possibility that Cailin is a wolf hiding behind Rangerism.
Post 5 - Says it's unnerving that Naria has yet to vote for an innocent. And for once, I agree.
Says she didn't realise how quiet she was but again advocates lynching the quiet. This seems very fishy. So... should we lynch you, Marco?
Says she thinks Form is the cobbler. I agree.
Doesn't suspect gil for being himself.
Post 6 - Says she will probably vote for Naria.
I'm afraid I don't have time for Gil just at the moment. After doing him, I'd like to take a look at Malka, Garin, SpM and Nilp, in that order. I fear SpM will be rather hefty though, and will not be able to manage it today.
Out of Naria and Marco, both seem suspicious. Naria's willingness to let others think for her, and her meaningless vote on day one, count against her. Marco's urgency to kill quiet people whilst ignoring herself is worrying. Neither goes out of their way to justify votes.
|