[Azaelia of Willowbottom]

I would say that the interaction between the actors was a big indicator for me: The rapport between Frodo and Sam, Pippin and Merry, just to name a few. The script was very well done, for the most part, but even the best script falls flat without good actors. I think the performers did really well as a whole. Or what about the parts without words? The scene at the Grey Havens was very well acted, but few words were spoken.

I tend to focus on the acting because I am at heart an actress, so great performances will stand out for me more than other things.

Also, the music is breathtaking, particularly Howard Shore's theme for Rohan. For me, the slightly sad but soaring sound of the string instruments he chose was perfect, and very evocative of the feel of Rohan from the books. I sometimes listen to the soundtracks while reading certain parts of the book, and they measure up to the moods expressed on the pages as well.