Farael: What can I say? Except - sorry, wrong. In some cases, I think you are simply reading too much into my words. In others, you seem to have misunderstood me. For instance, you say:
Quote:
|
And I think Aiwendil is also over-stating the problems the false seer might bring upon us.
|
But what I had in fact said was:
Quote:
|
I think people may be worrying a bit too much about the false Seer
|
If that's "over-stating the problems", I'll eat my hat (once it's been properly seasoned, of course).
Also, I did not claim "that the Seer is useless 'till dead". I said that it seems to me that the Seer's
greatest value is after he/she has been revealed (usually by death).
Anguirel wrote:
Quote:
|
And Boromir88, above all. For all Aiwendil's assertion that he looks like one of the helpful ones, he hasn't really said all that much, except the infamous "Seems to be business as usual" post.
|
You make a good point. Looking back, I see that
Boromir88 has appeared helpful while saying very little. It seems to me that this is just what a wolf would most like to do. However, I still don't see any particular reason to suspect
Boromir at this point.
My vote will probably go to
Tar-ancalime, for reasons stated earlier (and not to
Glirdan because it seems better for the votes to be spread out). But I am not pressed for time and I will consider things again before making that final.