Day 1 Lhuna voters (in order)
The Saucepan Man
Eomer of the Rohirrim
dancing spawn of ungoliant
Well, I was wrong about Lhuna obviously. But she did look the most likely to be a Wolf to me at the time.
Eomer drew her level on 2 votes with Gil-Galad, Glirdan and Boro. An understandable vote, perhaps, given that it was sensible to keep the voting tight, so as to make it difficult for the Wolves. But it could also have been a Wolfish attempt to put four innocents (assuming Glirdan and Boro are innocent) ahead in the voting.
Dancing spawn put her on 3 votes, ahead of Boro, Glirdan and tar-ancalime (on 2 votes each), at a time when Gil was on 4 votes. Not sure what that tells us, but it could again have been aimed at promoting innocents as the main candidates for lynching.
Day 2 Lhuna voters (in order)
Glirdan
Eomer of the Rohirrim
Anguirel
mormegil
littlemanpoet
I still think
Glirdan's early first vote for Lhuna on Day 2 looks un-Wolfish. Lhuna attracted the third highest number of votes on Day 1 and was therefore a possible contender for lynching on Day 2 at the time Glirdan voted for her. An early vote can attract suspicion. An early vote for someone who is later lynched and proved innocent moreso. Conversely, therefore, I think that Glirdan's vote speaks in his favour.
Eomer is the only villager to have voted twice for Lhuna and one of only three villagers to have voted twice for known innocents (Glirdan and morm are the others). So that immediately makes him look suspicious to me. Which makes me wonder whether a Wolf would have voted so riskily two Days running. Then again, an Eomer-Wolf would surely be a bold Wolf. Dancing spawn brought up some good points concerning Eomer yesterday and I think that it may be worth looking back over his posts and spawn's analysis of him.
Anguirel was innocent although his vote, putting Lhuna ahead as it did, would otherwise have looked suspicious today.
Now
mormegil, like Eomer, has voted twice for known innocents and his vote for Lhuna put her 2 votes ahead of anyone else. So that all makes him look quite suspicious. However, there's not much else to go on at the moment on morm and I still have the feeling that, if lmp is a Wolf, morm is probably innocent.
Littlemanpoet's vote was the one that sealed Lhuna's fate. Or was it? No, it wasn't. He voted last, at a time when Lhuna was on 4 votes and he was on 3. So Lhuna was already facing the gallows when he voted. Now, if lmp is a Wolf, why would he vote for an innocent who was guaranteed to be lynched? Why not place a "safe" vote elsewhere, or even a Wolf-on-Wolf vote?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by lmp
Gotta vote, and I want to survive.
|
He claimed that he was voting to save himself. When in fact he wasn't at all, as he surely would have known (even if he cross-posted with Boro, who voted for him). A "safe" vote at that stage might have looked suspicious, but his vote for Lhuna allows him to claim that he was forced into it (or, at least, that he thought he was).
So lmp remains my prime suspect. But, if there were two Wolves among the Lhuna votes, I have a feeling that Eomer might fit the bill.