Thoughts on villagers:
LMP – I would have defended lmp, but that’s now a moot point.
Boro – backs off attack on lmp early in the DAY, then defends him briefly in 241. Suspects Aiwendil, Spawn, Eomer and Kath. Gives thought that Sauce is still alive because he hasn’t identified a wolf. Tries to keep village focused on finding wolves instead of debating cryptic clues. Says he’ll be an observer today. For trying to keep focus and for defense of lmp, I’m willing to exonerate him.
SpM – gives voting record, as usual. Suspects lmp in 227, 231, 240, 243. Says that if the wolves attacked Ang because they thought he was gifted, it may point toward Glirdy’s or my innocence (but continues to suspect me). Expresses concern over Garin’s early vote. Denies being a wolf. Also suspects Eomer for his Lhuna vote, though less than lmp. Case for Eomer built more in 250. Most of the rest from this point on the anagrams and lmp controversies. Now votes for Kath due to her non vote yesterday, keeping her thoughts under wraps, and voting for Gil. Overall, I think he’s been very insightful, and I don’t think he’s a wolf.
Aiwendil – I continue to think that he’s innocent for his continuing detailed and interesting analysis. He hasn’t really done anything that makes me think he might be a wolf.
Farael – still don’t think I can suspect him. I continue to believe that the Aiwendil/Farael duel was two squabbling innocents.
Mormegil - someone I think is most likely innocent. Has posted thoughtful analysis throughout. Suspects Eomer, Garin, and LMP, mostly lmp. Thinks about voting for your local froggie in 102, or alternatively Garin/Eomer.
Glirdan – feels innocent to me. Expresses confusion over lmp’s suicidal vote, then votes for him, giving the reason that he wanted to help lmp get out of the game if that’s what he wanted. Says he may forego his vote today. That seems odd, but I’ll excuse it on the basis that this has been a very confusing day. We’ll see.
Tar-Ancalime – suspects lmp early. Defends Aiwendil and somewhat suspects Farael. Suspects Garin. Wants to watch Eomer and Spawn as well. Suggests getting rid of people who muddy things. Comments on Nilp and SpM hints. Doesn’t want to make a quick, unexamined vote. Doesn’t strike me as particularly wolvish.
Nilpaurion Felagund – not here yet toDAY. I didn’t suspect him before. Am willing to go with SpM’s analysis (I didn’t spot the anagrams before myself) for now and continue to give him the benefit of the doubt.
Formendacil – says he’s not feeling well and too muddled as a result to figure out what is going on. That’s about it. I don’t get a real idea of innocence or guilt.
Dancing Spawn of Ungoliant – suspects
Eomer. Gives a pretty detailed, reasonable argument. Doesn’t look that suspicious to me.
Eomer of the Rohirrim – resents spawn’s suspicions and gives a sarcastic reply. Presents a case against
spawn Believes lmp is a wolf, then votes for him after lmp’s request. Doesn’t suspect SpM, but accuses him of ‘channeling’ his suspect spawn’s thoughts. I can see why he looks suspicious, but there’s not really enough for me to go on to vote for him. Will watch.
Kath – hasn’t been around too much. Calls Garin on his request for Formendacil to vote (discussed below) – something that I think points to her innocence. Though I can’t totally go one way or the other on her. At any rate, I’m not willing to attack someone just for not being around frequently for obvious reasons.
Garin – continues to make me very, very uneasy today due to 1) early vote for Boro 2) a lot of defensiveness that didn’t really seem warranted given the large anti-lmp sentiment that held sway at the moment 3) asking Formendacil to hurry and vote – just seems like poor advice unless you’re trying to generate randomness and confusion and 4) I just generally have an odd feeling about him. I don’t know.
Actually, I do know. I’m going to stick with my vote from yesterday and say
++GARIN
He makes me far too uneasy, far more than anyone else so far.