|
A few thoughts on those who look like lynch candidates for toDAY:
Boromir - Never understood the strong suspicion of him. If he's a wolf, I'll be kicking myself pretty hard, but for the moment I'm inclined to think him innocent.
Kath - I don't blame her for her failure to vote yesterDAY. I can understand not wanting to cast a more or less random vote, and I don't think that Eomer is right that she should simply have voted for anyone who worried her slightly. Still, I think she's been doing a good job (up until toDAY, perhaps) of "flying under the radar". Somewhat suspicious.
Garin - Earlier, I said that my two main suspects toDAY were Garin and LMP. Well, obviously I was wrong about one of them, which does shake my confidence in the rest of my analyses. But Garin continues to look wolvish to me. In particular, it occurs to me that his stubborn attacks on Boromir would be a nice way for a wolf to avoid the "flip flop" accusation. He's a top suspect and will likely get my vote toDAY.
Eomer - I can see how he could be a wolf. Reading through his posts up to yesterDAY, he indeed looks fairly suspicious to me. But, to be honest, his defense toDAY comes across, to me at least, as that of an innocent. Yes, he's gotten a bit "shrill" (to use his own word). Let me remind you that LMP got shrill as well. It seems to me that a wolf would make more of a conscious effort not to come across as shrill and over-defensive. A wolf would look fairer and feel fouler, so to speak.
Formendacil - No votes for him yet, but I consider him here because he was one of my top suspects yesterDAY. I'm sorry to hear that he's feeling ill. More relevantly, I certainly don't think he'd make up a story about having the flu. So in my mind his relative silence is excused. There are still a few points that concern me here, but for now I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt.
All right - I may not make it back before the deadline, so I must vote. Garin looks the most suspicious to me right now (and indeed, he's the only person who has, from DAY 1, seemed consistently suspicious to me). I said we needed to lynch a wolf toDAY, and I think Garin's our best bet.
++Garin
|