[Kath]

Well no one really seemed to appreciate this but I find it helpful and if I don’t post it I’ll just be accused of being quiet and if I do it’ll be long posts with little to say. Ah well.

Day 2:

Anguirel – saw that Holby had supported morm, so perhaps the latter is innocent? However as said there is little evidence so that theory would have to be tested.

Celuien – claims she would never have picked Holby as Gifted. Ok but why make such a mention of it? Can’t see any clues in Holby’s posts and doesn’t think she dreamt of morm (which would make him innocent) because the evidence is too weak. Finds Lhuna’s comments odd and thinks lmp’s behaviour may have been a little furry.

Morm – suspects tar-a and lmp, though we can ignore the latter now. Builds up an argument against lmp that is now useless. I wonder though whether this fierce campaign could have been a wolvish attempt to avoid suspicion. That sounds odd but Eomer thought the wolves would be timid and someone else thought they would play to their strengths, so he would be going against Eomer which if morm was a wolf would put some suspicion on Eomer, and also thanks to Boromir’s ‘too usual’ post we just explain it as ‘morm being morm’ and he escapes suspicion. And yes I know not much of that made sense, it’s hard to explain. Cross about lmp’s reaction to his suspicion.

Glirdan – repeats that his vote for Gil was random and asks to be excluded from suspicion. Wants to look at those who jumped on his ‘lynch the quiet ones’ campaign as it was only to generate conversation not actually meant. Specifically means Lhuna here. There is a funny ‘we’ when talking of how the wolves would act which at first glance seems to suggest he is one of them, but I don’t think he’d be that stupid! Belatedly answers Aiwendil’s questions but not in any way that would really help the wolves. Goes on at Lhuna about the quietness thing, claiming he has the same timezone worries though, unless he secretly lives in the Philippines, I don’t believe he does. Votes Lhuna based on these worries.

Aiwendil – makes a point of saying he didn’t think Holby the Seer. Doesn’t understand the votes for Gil or Boromir. Thinks Form and Garin look the most suspicious. Also thinks tar-a is still suspicious for her attacking and then backing off pattern, and for her vote for Eomer as he feels it was ‘safe’. Seems to suspect Glirdan but thinks the other are more suspicious. Finds the anti-Boromir campaign suspicious because while villagers and wolves sound the same they don’t vote the same, and he thinks these Boromir votes show that. Thinks Form suspicious for his vote. Thinks Garin’s vote looks wolvish with him either trying to save a wolf or just get Gil killed. Thinks lmp is behaving oddly. Doesn’t think Farael suspicious, but wonders if he is the False Seer after wondering the same thing of lmp. Seems a thinly veiled attempt to root out the remaining Seer to me. Suspects Form and Garin. Utterly agreed on the latter right now.

Boromir – thinks the wolves may be trying to set up Lhuna and tar-a. Thinks morm, SPM and spawn innocent (I am inclined to agree with the last two). Lhuna, Garin and lmp considered suspicious along with Celuien. Suspects these people also because they fanned the Seer discussion, which he beleives was a wolvish ploy. Says he honestly believed he had to vote Gil to save himself but takes back suspicion of lmp since he had now realised this. Accuses lmp.

Form – argues that his vote for Boromir was reasoned, though not really due to suspicions. But then he doesn’t believe in Day 1’s so that makes sense even if it is a little odd. Thinks Garin more likely to be an innocent than a wolf though won’t discount the possibility that he could be one. A bit indecisive.

Garin – explains his vote. Thinks Boromir suspicious due to his flurry of late posting. Defends his vote for Boromir. Woah! Earlier claimed that the False Seer was but a useless villager and should come forward, now condemns lmp for doing the exact same thing! That’s not flipflopping, that’s hypocrisy!

Lmp – explains the knife comment, unfortunately along with some nasty names. Argues against morm, and we now know he is innocent so perhaps morm’s big thing against him is a little suspicious, or actually a lot suspicious. Thinks SPM, Farael, Aiwendil, spawn and Ang innocent. Finds morm, Form, Kath, Garin Celuien and Boromir suspicious. Top three suspects are morm, Form and Boro, and I am increasingly agreed on the first of that triad. Suddenly though Garin becomes most suspicious to him. Explains his suspicions of Boromir.

SPM – thinks Holby’s death was an attempt to frame tar-a, and so thinks the latter innocent. Thinks the votes for Boromir odd. Suspects the Gil voters. Could go either way on Boro’s vote for Gil. Now, I am starting to find that more and more suspicious since he did not need to vote for Gil to save his own life. It was an easy excuse for a ‘safe’ vote. Thinks Glirdan and tar-a innocent and Lhuna suspicious. Therefore suspicious of morm, Kath, Celuien, lmp and Lhuna. Supports lmp against mormegil over the knife comment. Thinks Aiwedil, lmp and Celuien (learn to spell it SPM!) suspicious over the Seer talking.

Nilp – thinks those on the Boromir bandwagon suspicious since it started so suddenly and so late. Also not keen on those who voted for Gil since he saw no reasoning behind it. Thinks those that voted Lhuna are innocent if misguided. Thinks tar-a and Eomer may be wolves based on the ‘safe’ vote. Thinks Farael innocent. Thinks those who voted Gil and tar-a are innocent. So suspicious of lmp, Ang, tar-a, Form and Garin. The first two we know to be innocent, what about the last 3?

Tar-a – Defends Boromir but makes a points of not being allied with him. Unsure over Garin because of his questioning of Boromir. Doesn’t get the Boromir bandwagon.


That's as far as I have time to go but actually I'm quite happy with where I've stopped having just noticed that little comment of Garin's. I have absolutely no regret with voting

++GARIN

You've been speaking of hypocrisy Eomer, here is a prime example!