Oh, this was a lot of work.
Thin's Analysis
Day 1
1st post - Rhyme about RL issues, questions Nogrod, says first day is all nonsense.
2nd - Greets Jenny, agrees that looking at Ang for rhymes and Valier for typed accent is a good place to start.
3rd - Double post. Comes against with evidence against Roa based on Sleepy's posts, but says she's not accusing her. Says previous remark on role-playing is generally nonsense.
4th - Triple post. Questions Ang's lack of suspicion for her.
5th - Quadruple post. Agrees on giving more time to the silent ones. Says W_Q's silence is not enough to convict.
6th - Quintuple post. Questions own reasoning on Ang, wonders if Jenny has completed her analysis.
7th - Would be sextuple post, except cross-posted with Holbytlass. Changes mind and says she understands Nogrod's point about nonsense posts.
8th - Double post. Agrees that non-voting doesn't help. Agrees that Naria and Valier are "slippery" but there is time left for them to improve posts. Thinks Jenny isn't as bad.
9th - Triple post. Agrees with Naria that waiting is really all one can do on first day. Suggests that the enemy is one that no one has yet suspected. Thinks accusing everyone wouldn't be helpful, but also thinks that watching the reactions to accusations is. Lists votes.
10th - Wonders about the "pressing the silent one's" theory, and about the grouping on that idea.
11th - Nothing post.
12th - Says again that first day is nonsense.
13th - Again wonders about the "silence theory"
14th - Reanalyzes day and realizes that there really was no grouping on the "silence theory"
15th - Thinks Ang is moving on the "silence theory" trend, points out Enca's lack of substance
16th - Thinks Roa's theory is a good one.
17th - Says theory is better, and Roa is unlikely a wolf.
18th - Sarcasm at Eonwe's method of voting. Thinks that some formula is possible. More sarcasm at Eonwe's theory.
19th - Wonders why Roa thinks Sleepy would use "that kind of subtlety"
20th - Wonders about opening poem. Looks at hint in Naria's post, but brushes it off.
21st - Thinks looking at avies is over-kill.
22nd - Replies to LMP's post.
23rd- Says she's accusing Ka rather than defending her. Quotes herself to show defense and attack. Thinks Roa's theory is solid, but doesn't want to take sides.
24th - Wants to hear from Gil, Valesse and Valier.
25th- Agrees that Sleepy is clever, thinks she will bandwagon on the Ka vote
26th - Says Valier is using her accent as a cover.
27th - Nothing post
28th - Says Valier is assuming that the accent will take attention from her posts. Asks why Valier distrusts Nogrod and trust Ka
29th - Nothing post
30th - Points out that she brings up more than one side of the matter. Says she isn't accusing Enca.
31st - Doesn't blame Valier's gut instinct. Votes Ka admits to bandwagon but believes Ka is the most suspicious.
Day 2
No posts yet (Thank God. That was tedious.)
__________________
We can't all be Roas when it comes to analysing... -Lommy
I didn't say you're evil, Roa, I said you're exasperating. -Nerwen
|