[Anguirel]

And in the midst of the controversy, my Case Against Elendil, work of a morning's diligent ranting, gets no love?

Honestly. This mass-boycotting is uncalled for...

I would suggest that Formendacil lay down his rules and reveal his criteria clearly, since you're all being so stuffy about this; but I don't see any need for throwing out or dragging in candidates. It'll send us scrabbling over old material.

On the other hand, if there must be a choice due to you all being revolting peasants, Elrond not Celeborn must go, Oropher not Khamul return. If we're going to revise one candidate by stringent-mode, we'll have to revise all the other non-stringent votes-completely warping the game as it has enjoyably proceeded so far.

For myself, I continue to regard this game and Formendacil's modding as the most enjoyable Survivor so far.