Here’s a shortcut to the most heated discussion: and please people, inform me if I have interpreted yourselves wrongly. This is just how I saw that one piece of argument. I’ll send it like this and come at least for one mail to have some ideas about it, before I go to sleep.
Kuruharan #93: defends Jenny’s innocence, and comes to suspect me again – although admitting that my doings would be an doings of an innocent (= no reason given for this suspicion!). Interesting twist, as she withdraw his vote from me to vote Jenny at the last moment, making it possible to kill a wolf....
Boromir #94: Attacks mildly Firefoot, full swing against Kuru (on the basis of them joking).
Jenny #97: Points to Kuru’s weak evidence against her.
Kuru #101: Denies being answerable to the whims by Fea. Minimally shoves off Jenny’s arguments: suspecting her of piggy-backing.
Jenny #103: Noting Kuru, that she had a bad argument as she had been the first of them to vote for me... so no pig-backing.
Boromir #106: Very assured. He got Feanor, he has Kuru also, because of the wolves having a amiable chat with each other. (Was he the one to come up with this “Fea’s the wolf” –thing?)
Kuru #107: Shields a brag from Boromir, apologizes for his mistake with Jenny, defends not voting for Fea.
Firefoot #109: Denies Boro’s reasoning about my guiltlesness with some good grounds – Boro came up with nothing to back it – but also odd grounds: I would have changed my vote at that last instant in any case: not only, if I’d be a wolf, but more so, as I am a villager (otherwise I should have had very firm grounds to believe, Fea was the seer – otherwise I wouldn’t have sacrificed myself – and my sacrifice would have taken a self-vote!). Denies anything that Fea said, could be of any interest.
Boro #111: Incredible argument about my different guilt by changing votes at the last instance, whethwer Fea was innocent or not. No logic at all! Then even more dubious argument: he thinks I’m “clean” because I contributed to the lynching of a wolf! I was just saving myself – I even apologized Fea publicly about it! Accuses Firefoot.
Firefoot #112: Checking Boro – post 27 Boro brings together Fea and Jenny as “lighthearted”. Almost accusing Boro of safe-voting a fellow wolf and then actually bragging about his cleanliness by that.
Jenny #113: Voices her growing suspicion about Boro. Clears Firefoot.
Boromir #115: Makes a very strong attack on Kuru, by his assuredness – and being right already before. Proclaims himself annoyed, because no-one believes him.
WOW. About all of these people seem to be talking illogically or arguing very badly! We can't have this many wolves!!!
