Illusionary Holbytla
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 7,547
|
Alrighty, time to take a comprehensive look at everybody. For those of you who are unfamiliar with my style of analysis (this kind), the "," separates points in the same post, the ";" separates different posts, and the ";;" separates Day 1 and Day 2. The "." indicates the end of the sum up and the start of my analysis. I didn't include posts that held no apparent substance to them (e.g., the drug war posts at the start).
Jenny Hallu - is wary not suspicious of Nogrod, wants more substance from Gil, votes Gil; changes vote to Nogrod for being bloodthirsty; Nogrod - "hasty and illogical", Gil - annoying, Sleepy - vote is "odd but reasonable", Fea - "erratic", Boro - "reasonable and logical", Kuru - somewhat suspicious, Firefoot - "reasonable and logical", decides for the time being to leave her vote with Nogrod; two corrections to others' statements; defends herself to others' claims that she has been erratic and petty;; defends herself for thinking Fea innocent; thinks Nogrod is probably innocent, explains suspicion of Kuru; comments about how much effort "most people" put into wording their posts; Boro - looking more and more suspicious, thinks Nogrod innocent, still concerned about Kuru, worries about Diamond's apparent wishy-washyness, calls Oddwen, Kitanna, and Zali too quiet, Gil - hopefully innocent, Morm - unknown, me - probably innocent; inclined to believe Boro's claim; analysis of Fea's posts; analysis of Kuru's posts. My overall impression of her is innocent. She does post a lot, but it's not all wishy-washy; there is some substance to it and I can usually see where she is coming from. Not off the radar yet, but rather low.
Kitanna - is somewhat suspicious of Nogrod, feels his first three reasons for wanting to lynch silent people have some merit; Nogrod more suspicious than Morm, Gil unhelpful, Fea neutral suspicion, Sleepy unhelpful, doesn't want to vote any of them, votes Kuru mostly randomly;; Jenny - petty, Boro and Kuru - plenty of room for doubt, overall leaning towards Kuru's guilt rather than Boro's; in order of suspicion: Kuru, Jenny, Boromir; votes Kuru. I can see a possibility for a wolf here. She was not alone in her suspicion of Kuru, of course, but I can certainly see potential for a wolf going for another wolf. Not sure though; she could be innocent. Somewhere in the middle.
Diamond18 - gets quite defensive over Boromir's initial accusation of her, attempts to turn the tables around and shed some suspicion on him; is confused about who to vote for; votes Nogrod;; thinks Nogrod is proably innocent but ticked off with her, isn't sure about Jenny - sees possible connection with Fea, finds Kuru highly suspicious, isn't sure whether Morm's start of the lynch-Nogrod mob meant anything, not sure about Boro, confused about me, not much to say about Oddwen, Kitanna, Gil, and Zali; leaning towards Kuru's innocence from his interactions with Fea; says my point of most people not needing to choose carefully their words was good; defends herself to Jenny and says that she is not just agreeing with everything everyone says; lists possibilities of what Boro could really be with his claim to be seer; votes Kuru; Nogrod and Jenny - innocent, me - suspicious. Diamond seems to be a little all over the place. Some of her posts I think she could be a wolf and others not. I'm watching her but not completely suspicious of her.
Mormegil - votes Nogrod for his haste in accusing silent ones; points out Boromir's contradicting opinions about him; defends himself to Nogrod (gives air or irritation); first points out the "Fea's a wolf" line; changes vote to Fea;; posts voting, Jenny - suspicious, says Oddwen's, Kitanna's, Diamond's, and Jenny's votes of interest, is leaning towards Nogrod's innocence; growing suspicion of Jenny, groupings for suspicion (most to least): [Azaelia Oddwen Kitanna] [Diamond Boro Firefoot Jenny Nogrod] [Morm Kuru Gil]; vote Kuru; requests Boro's reasons for suspecting me; frustrated with Gil. Morm seems to be acting pretty consistently with my experience with him; however, this doesn't necessarily mean anything. He's smart enough to be able to pull it off as a wolf. I'd say leaning more innocent than guilty.
Nogrod - expresses concern over silent ones, proposes lynching one of them on the first day; comes up with his (faulty) statistics, continues proposing the silent ones be lynched; responds to people's accusations of him; gets frustrated at people's continued accusations of him for his idea of lynching silent ones; votes morm for being hypocritical, voting hastily for him, being bloodthirsty, and having an arrogant playing style; changes vote to Gil; calls Morm's actions "rampant madness," wonders why he ignores the posts of for example me, Kitanna, and Fea (significance here? or just random names?); changes vote to Fea;; comments about the amazing circumstances of Fea's death; comments that Jenny's playing style says little or nothing about her wolvishness; wants some explanation from Boro; frustrated with Gil; provides a sum-up of recent discussion; votes Kuru. Nogrod seems more like a frustrated innocent than a wolf to me, but I'm not sure. On the whole I'd say he seems fairly genuine.
Gil-galad - "alas, alas" post;; votes Kuru. Nothing to say here...
Azaelia - comes down on Nogrod for accusing the silent ones, threatens that she will probably be voting for him; votes Nogrod, wants people to vote based on the person and what they're saying rather than how loud or quiet they are;; Nogrod not sitting right, believed Boro innocent even before his seer claim, about ready to vote for Kuru; votes Kuru; Nogrod - probably innocent, Gil - unknown, Diamond - probably innocent, Jenny - hard to figure out, but probably innocent, me - somewhat guilty, morm - dangerous if a wolf, Oddwen - confusing, Kitanna - probably innocent. She seems pretty innocent to me.
Oddwen - doesn't think that vocal people are necessarily helpful; votes Sleepy;; unsure about Nogrod, votes Morm (...?). I would definitely like to hear more from Oddwen. Her posts are extremely lacking in substance.
Now a look at Fea's analysis (for clarification: I did not mean that we should not look at it at all. I meant that it should be read with a grain of salt). From her post, I would be inclined to think Nogrod and Morm more innocent, while looking more closely at Kitanna, Jenny, and Zali. Lining that up with my earlier thoughts, it would seem to point towards Kitanna as a wolf. I'm not convinced that this is so, however; thankfully there's another day to decide all of this.
Phew! That certainly took a while.
|