Quote:
|
Conclusion: If the wolves did think Celuien is the Seer, then LMP, and probably Naria and Gurthang, are innocents. I find little evidence of new wolvish candidates here, however, except possibly Samwise.
|
Thanks Lalaith - very thorough.
However, I disagree with your conclusion. If the wolves thought Celuien the Seer, it would make Samwise (in principle) look less suspicious since Celuien did not pursue her suspicions any further, which she would have done if she had dreamt of Wolf-Samwise. It rather suggests a dream of Samwise and finding him innocent. Though Celuien was not the Seer of course; but it certainly does not make Samwise look more lupine. I hope that made sense.
I agree with the rest of your conclusion, but we cannot trust Celuien's words blindly.