Quote:
|
Originally Posted by littlemanpoet
I'm debating with myself whether there's really a difference between Olórin and Gandalf the White. I'm not sure there is.
|
You're unaware of the difference between a Maia in its natural incorporeal form and one that has been fully incarnated in the form of an old man?
Here's how I would design the list:
RED: [gods - Valar] *Melkor; *Manwe
RED-ORANGE: [unknown] Ungoliante? Tom Bombadil?
ORANGE: [angels - Maiar] *Eonwe; Arien; *Sauron; *Olorin; Melian; Curumo; Gothmog; Huan
ORANGE: [demigods - Eldar] *Luthien; *Galadriel; *Feanor; Glorfindel; Ecthelion; Galdor?
ORANGE: [creatures - Dragons and Others] *Ancalagon; Glaurung; Carcharoth; Smaug; Draugluin
YELLOW: [heroes - Eldar, Atani, Dwarves] *Hurin; Turin; Tuor; Beren; Thrain; Aragorn
GREEN: [the children - Elves, Men/Hobbits, Dwarves] Celeborn; Boromir; Legolas
BLUE: [lesser humanoids - Orcs]
BABY BLUE: [beasts]
Colors indicate possible overlaps between categories. For example, Ungoliante might be considered more powerful than some Valar. Another example is Ancalagon and Glaurung being on par with the Maiar, perhaps. Rankings in each bracket are more or less approximate, except where marked by an asterisk, which indicates that the individual is fairly certainly in the correct position (usually the top positions of the tier). Obviously my list isn't as extensive as yours, but I don't necessarily think it should be. Some things go without saying, and many individuals are impossible to gauge.