The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XX: Wereorc I: The elves cannot hide themselves much longer.

Celuien · 04-14-2006, 07:00 PM

Zali:
#51: Apologies for not being present. Cites school, illness, dinner. Agrees that dream revelations are at the receiver’s discretion. Cautions against obvious hints as reason to be targeted by orcs, but wants some indication so that dreams can be found should the poster be killed.
#60: Analysis of posters with error about Caran’s position on dream revealing. Thinks Spawn is innocent, wants to watch Diamond, Glirdan and Sleepy, doesn’t know about the rest.
#82: Apologizes for error about Caran’s post. Asks Sleepy about channeling Nilp. Says that Diamond’s most recent post seems innocent and she’ll vote for either Glirdan or Sleepy, finding both equally suspicious (though agreeing with Kitanna that Sleepy may be too bold for an orc). Votes Glirdan, then apologizes for vote if he turns out to be innocent while pointing out that the vote is based on actual suspicion.

What do I think of this? Somewhat suspicious. I don’t like apologies for votes when they’re based on suspicion. That’s the reason to vote for someone…unless you know they’re innocent and you’re covering tracks. Vote also come at prime bandwagon hiding time. Will watch.

Grendelien:
#24: Laments Farael. Will miss his skipping Na over pond water (!!!). Says that dreams are a double-edged sword, apologizes for repeating everyone’s thoughts on the dreams, agrees with Caran’s plan.
#83: Expresses confusion over who to vote for. Says that Diamond’s lack of substance is suspicious, but that Nogrod and I could be wolves trying to cause a diversion by writing detailed posts. Votes Glirdan because of suspicion of the Diamond voters, though thinking that it isn’t a good reason to vote for someone.

Again, not a whole lot to go on. Overall feel is non-suspicious based on fairly good logic, though I would have liked to hear a little more. Actually voting for Glirdan based on suspicion of the Diamond voters is reasonable, since if Grendelien did suspect the Diamond voters, it would have been an indication of her innocence. I’d like to hear more about which of the Diamond voters were found most suspicious.

In the overall overall, the most suspicious Glirdan voter from my perspective is Zali.

And that’s all for now!

04-14-2006, 07:00 PM	#117
Celuien Riveting Ribbiter Join Date: May 2005 Location: Assigned to Mordor Posts: 1,767	Zali: #51: Apologies for not being present. Cites school, illness, dinner. Agrees that dream revelations are at the receiver’s discretion. Cautions against obvious hints as reason to be targeted by orcs, but wants some indication so that dreams can be found should the poster be killed. #60: Analysis of posters with error about Caran’s position on dream revealing. Thinks Spawn is innocent, wants to watch Diamond, Glirdan and Sleepy, doesn’t know about the rest. #82: Apologizes for error about Caran’s post. Asks Sleepy about channeling Nilp. Says that Diamond’s most recent post seems innocent and she’ll vote for either Glirdan or Sleepy, finding both equally suspicious (though agreeing with Kitanna that Sleepy may be too bold for an orc). Votes Glirdan, then apologizes for vote if he turns out to be innocent while pointing out that the vote is based on actual suspicion. What do I think of this? Somewhat suspicious. I don’t like apologies for votes when they’re based on suspicion. That’s the reason to vote for someone…unless you know they’re innocent and you’re covering tracks. Vote also come at prime bandwagon hiding time. Will watch. Grendelien: #24: Laments Farael. Will miss his skipping Na over pond water (!!!). Says that dreams are a double-edged sword, apologizes for repeating everyone’s thoughts on the dreams, agrees with Caran’s plan. #83: Expresses confusion over who to vote for. Says that Diamond’s lack of substance is suspicious, but that Nogrod and I could be wolves trying to cause a diversion by writing detailed posts. Votes Glirdan because of suspicion of the Diamond voters, though thinking that it isn’t a good reason to vote for someone. Again, not a whole lot to go on. Overall feel is non-suspicious based on fairly good logic, though I would have liked to hear a little more. Actually voting for Glirdan based on suspicion of the Diamond voters is reasonable, since if Grendelien did suspect the Diamond voters, it would have been an indication of her innocence. I’d like to hear more about which of the Diamond voters were found most suspicious. In the overall overall, the most suspicious Glirdan voter from my perspective is Zali. And that’s all for now! __________________ People assume that time is a strict progression of cause to effect. But actually, from a non-linear, non-subjective viewpoint, it's more like a big ball of wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey... stuff.