That was a job! Good God! And I see you have been faster than me...
But for hard-core weregamers, this should be intresting indeed. I'll reserve my interpretation to a later moment - as I have time to come up with it - but this really opened some new interpretations I hadn't thought of before...
So
The first three accusations made, could be counted in the joke-compartment (but in a WW-game you never know about these either).
First Jenny and Celuien crooss-posted (random) accusations
Jenny #13: Spawn & Roa (too innocent), Sleepy (being a barrell), Diamond (having good time & not seeing the imminent end of the world)
Celuien #14: Using the “Random Illuminator™”, which revealed: Grendelien, Sleepy & Spawn
Third joke-one was:
Diamond #18: Caranlodien & Roa (always hanging together)
Then we came to some more thought of accusations / suspicions – and some of this stuff is quite interesting indeed (getting better towards the end, but there are a few interesting things quite early on too):
Spawn #35: Suspecting Diamond for chatting to avoid “under radar” suspicions. Roa about excusing random voting and taking time to answer Jenny’s joke accusation. Findëasëa, for posting only once – then retreating with first-timer issue. Sleepy, for not being serious although saying he is.
Kitanna#37 Agrees with Spawn’s suspicions – even not agreeing with them all. Mostly suspects Roa and Diamond.
Caran #38 Agrees with Spawn’s suspicions – adds to be suspecting everyone.
Nogrod #39 Makes a list of people, leaving the “most suspicious” to the bottom (without any clear indication of there being an order in the list): Diamond and Sleepy.
Caran #40 Defends Grendelien & Findëasëa, as newbies. Agrees with the suspicions of Diamond (lots of posts with no substance cover guilt) and Sleepy (not posting enough)!
Nogrod #42 Says wouldn’t vote for Celuien, Roa, Spawn, Jenny & Caranlodien. Says Diamond “somewhat suspicious”, ans Sleepy’s gaming style suspicious (although known). Agreeing with Caran about the newbies.
Spawn #45 Just votes boldly for Roa, with no further reason given...
Celuien #46 Votes for Diamond: too agreeable (+ others have stated more reasons). Noting that Nogrod, Caran, Spawn, Kitanna, and Caran seem particularly unsuspicious. Wants to give newbies the benefit of doubt. Wants to watch Glirdan, will think about Roa, Naria & Sleepy.
Roa #47 Votes for Glirdan (just restating others opinions & known to able to do more), suspects Diamond (lack of content).
Jenny #48 Finds suspicious: Nogrod for his own reasoning: Anyone fighting against a good idea is an orc!, Diamond for general hyperness, and Sleepy for promoting random votes
Sleepy #49 Voting Jenny for her accusation for him.
Glirdan #50 Voting Sleepy (“completely random”).
Jenny #53 Voting for Diamond (votes are already spread enough).
Findëasëa #56 Voting Glirdan (little substance + random voting as a cover?).
Zali #60 Puts Glirdan, Sleepy (random votes) and Diamond (no substance) on the “watch list”. “leaning towards innocent: Spawn (looks innocent and logical)
Nogrod #61 Says, he is uneasy about Diamond & Glirdan being first in the lynch-line, although he has his suspicions on both of them (not playing like they normally do).
Kitanna #62 Votes Sleepy (for being, not suspicious, but “childish”), agrees with Spawn lightly about suspicions for Roa.
Caran #63 Votes Diamond over Sleepy (“by gut”).
Nogrod #71 Expresses frustration on Sleepy – kind of believing him innocent.
Diamond #72 Votes for Glirdan (to save her butt).
Celuien #73 Thinks Nogrod innocent (genuine motivation + well-reasoned and informative).
Nogrod #74 Welcomes Diamond’s post and drops suspicion on her.
Sleepy #76 “Diamond’s alright” (right mind-set).
Celuien #78 Feeling bad for voting Diamond.
Nogrod #79 Sleepy wants to die, but that sounds bad, Glirdan has not been so bad, Diamond feels innocent
Zali #82 Chooses between Sleepy & Glirdan, votes Glirdan. Gives Diamond the benefit of doubt.
Grendelien #83 Votes for Glirdan and suspect those who have voted Diamond (whom she also admits being suspicious), Wonders, whether analysis by Celuien and Nogrod could be a diversions.
Nogrod #85 X-posts with a lot of stuff: reinstates that Glirdy would be useful as an innocent, Diamond possibly more so. Would be ready to give Sleepy the death he desires (as the least bad from the three options at hand).
Nogrod #88 Votes for Sleepy, as Glirdan is practically dead already, and Sleepy insisted...
EDIT: X-posted with millions...