Okay, as to interpretations:
As I hinted at in my analysis, I find Jenny's posts suspicious, in that her first two seem to contradict each other:
Quote:
#13 Mostly all in character, but talks about having thought about the Shaman dreams and says she agrees with Celuien.
#29 Says she’ll be in and out. Says to quit obsessing over the dreams and agreeing with each other, says to focus on finding and Orc.
|
In her first posts she talks about the dreams and agrees with someone, in her second post chastises everyone else for doing that same thing as she has done.
In her very next posts she levels accusations, which seems to me hasty for a third post. Very quick to form suspicions and make judgments, and is slightly hypocritical. I am not sure how suspicious to find her though, since part of my suspicion stems from annoyance with the way she is quick to condemn people for not playing the game the way she thinks they should. This isn't necessarily wolfish, it could just be Jennyish. I'll withold making a desicion until I can track more.
Nogrod posts the most of any player, and this is usual for him. He's the first to make suggestions and form theories about how to use the Shaman role. I think I tend to assume Nogrod is innocent from the get go, because I like the kinds of posts he makes, which could be an unhealthy mindset. He's kind of like the reverse of the coin of Jenny for me. I'm automatically suspicious of her and automatically trusting of him. So should I trust my gut on these two or realize when I'm not objective enough? I hate to go against my gut, but I hate to be irrational, too. Nogrod and Jenny are probably two people I'll be leaving alone until I can get past my automatic mindsets.
Next to Nogrod Roa posts the most. I don't really see anything terribly suspicious in her posts, or incongruent with the way I've seen her post as an innocent. But there's nothing saying "definitely innocent" either. I'm pretty neutral so far. Plus I think I hesitate to want to kill off people who are active and invested in the game. So I doubt I'll be voting for her unless something really interesting happens.
Celuien voted for me, and then seemed to regret it after I showed up. Feels genuine, but then since I know that I am innocent, I can't help but wonder if she was getting ready a Day 2 defense for herself should I die. Still, gut feeling is that her reasons/opinions were genuine from an innocent point of view.
Caran I find suspicious. She voted for me because other people were suspicious of me, which seems a lot like bandwaggoning to avoid having own opinion. She also thought Sleepy was more substantial than me, and in my view Sleepy was just weird and off the wall, stirring the pot and hardly substantial by anyone's measure of substance. I'd like to know what exactly tipped the scales in that matter.
Speaking of Sleepy. Is he crazy? Or crazy like a fox? A dork, or an orc? Is begging to be killed a good way to stay alive? Strange, strange little apple barrel. I've got mine eye on you....
Findëasëa was very contradictory, voting for Glirdan based on lack of substance and posting, after having only made one short post herself. I'm not going to condem this automatically since she's new (to the board as well as the game) but I think there's a danger in being too patient for too long. I can easily see her fellow Orcs and her deciding to play the "newbie" role. In other words, she could be more savvie than she appears. (I don't mean this as an insult, Fin, if you are an innocent, I just don't know anything about you to know whether you are a quiet type usually.)
Grend posted a little more, voiced some opinion on the matter of my impending doom, I'm waiting for some more before I can really make a desicion. Comments about Find and newbieness also apply here, though she was a little more outspoken.
As long as I'm doing newbies, there's LiS. I'm a little baffled by you, LiS -- did you read the rules for Werewolf before playing? Hopefully you'll get the hang of it soon.
Kitanna was very quiet, so I'm a little suspicious of her. But as she didn't post much, there's not much to go on. Her vote for Sleepy wasn't really suspicious seeing as how off the wall Sleepy was acting.
Naria only posted twice, very short posts, and didn't vote, due to the RL concerns. But I'm still a little baffled by her accusing me today of not being helpful, as she's really in no position to judge at the moment.
Spawn only made a few posts but they weren't suspicious to me. Or, I should say, not overly suspicious, since I'm always suspicious of people who just seem innocent.
Zali is actually pretty much the same as Spawn, her number of posts were similar and the content was actually similar in a way (analysis and suspicions of players followed by voting). This is actually the most suspicious thing about Spawn and Zali -- that they behaved somewhat similarly and Zali name only Spawn as likely innocent (besides her own self).
I'm not going to base my vote toDay solely on yesterDay's activity though, so I now await the continuation of toDay's activity.