|
Dancing Spawn:
#31: laments Farael; suggests that dreamers leave hints through well-reasoned arguments, so that once a dreamer dies, we can easily tell whom they dreamed of.
My thoughts: I think that the merit of Spawn’s suggestion here depends on the answer to this question: When a dreamer dies, do we find out that they were a dreamer?
In the post after Spawn’s, Nogrod answers that question: No. Since Farael hasn’t contradicted this, I’m assuming that it’s true; When a dreamer dies, we don’t find out that they were a dreamer.
#34: acknowleges Nogrod’s reply; decides to comment on other villagers’ behaviors; points out Diamond for making many in-character posts with little substance; says Roa makes her uneasy because of her “subtle way of excusing random voting”, wonders why Roa took the time to answer Jenny’s in-character accusation; thinks Findeasea’s behavior odd, but excuses her for now as a newbie; thinks Sleepy Ranger isn’t taking the game very seriously.
My thoughts: Her attack on Roa is, as Nogrod has said, somewhat odd. I’m not sure what I think about Roa (that’s a whole other analysis), but as for Spawn, her reasoning isn’t up to par. Jenny made a tongue-in-cheek accusation, and Roa made a tongue-in-cheek response.
#44: votes for Roa
My thoughts: I don't find her dream suggestion that odd, as it could have resulted from the ambiguity concerning dead dreamers. Her attack on Roa does seem odd. But it was Day 1, and lots of people were acting strange. I'll reserve judgment on Spawn until seeing her behavior today.
|