The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - The Silmarillion- A classic Cult Comedy

narfforc · 04-22-2006, 06:28 AM

Have you ever thought of who would appear as your favourite characters if Tolkien had been a Comedy Writer for TV and Film

Eru: Expensive cardboard cutout with moving mouth parts, or Mel Brooks

Melkor: John Cleese

Manwe: Michael Palin

Mandos: Lurch

Aule: Phil Silvers

Feanor: Benny Hill

The Seven Sons of Feanor: Laurel and Hardy, Abbott and Costello, The Marx Brothers.

Fingolfin: Frankie Howerd

Melian and Thingol: Gomez and Morticia Adams

Luthien: Marilyn Munster

Beren: Eric Idle

Huan: Scooby-do

Carcharoth: Wil-e-coyote

The hand of Beren Erchamion: Thing (Addams Family)

Ar-Pharazon: Kenneth Williams

Sauron: Sid James

Hurin and Turin: Steptoe and Son

Huor and Tuor: Bernard Bresslaw and Charles Hawtrey

Elros and Elrond: The Likely Lads

The Orcs: Jerry Lewis and Jim Carey x1000000 by the wonder of CGI

The Elves: Any tall beautiful young narcissist, with long hair. Most Models will do.

The Dwarves: Danny DeVito, Cousin Itt and Mickey Rooney

The Dragons: H.R. Puffnstuff and Barney.

Well there's some to be going on with, if you can think of anyone who would fit the character better or ones I have missed, enter them here

04-22-2006, 06:28 AM	#1
narfforc Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Muddy-earth Posts: 1,297	The Silmarillion- A classic Cult Comedy Have you ever thought of who would appear as your favourite characters if Tolkien had been a Comedy Writer for TV and Film Eru: Expensive cardboard cutout with moving mouth parts, or Mel Brooks Melkor: John Cleese Manwe: Michael Palin Mandos: Lurch Aule: Phil Silvers Feanor: Benny Hill The Seven Sons of Feanor: Laurel and Hardy, Abbott and Costello, The Marx Brothers. Fingolfin: Frankie Howerd Melian and Thingol: Gomez and Morticia Adams Luthien: Marilyn Munster Beren: Eric Idle Huan: Scooby-do Carcharoth: Wil-e-coyote The hand of Beren Erchamion: Thing (Addams Family) Ar-Pharazon: Kenneth Williams Sauron: Sid James Hurin and Turin: Steptoe and Son Huor and Tuor: Bernard Bresslaw and Charles Hawtrey Elros and Elrond: The Likely Lads The Orcs: Jerry Lewis and Jim Carey x1000000 by the wonder of CGI The Elves: Any tall beautiful young narcissist, with long hair. Most Models will do. The Dwarves: Danny DeVito, Cousin Itt and Mickey Rooney The Dragons: H.R. Puffnstuff and Barney. Well there's some to be going on with, if you can think of anyone who would fit the character better or ones I have missed, enter them here __________________ [B]THE LORD OF THE GRINS:THE ONE PARODY....A PARODY BETTER THAN THE RINGS OF POWER.