Well some thoughts about those in the mildly suspecting Nilp -list. (I had made the Spm -part already before reading about Mith's dream, so excuse me, but for later goose-stuff, consider this also...)
Spm.
Somewhat seems to turn his cart, but then again, there is discussion of Mith in his post #73 being suspicious, which probably was X-posted with Mith's #72, where she said:
Quote:
|
It worries me when peopel I know aren't stupid act stupidly. Saucepanman isn't ringing true to me.
|
I quess some egoes would not take this and turn their opinion to vote the accuser...
(Sorry Sauce, couldn't resist that one!)
But anyhow. Spm does not seem to me a duckish villager.
Roa
Seems to be somewhat aiding Nilp, but not too obviously (it might be just her cunningness here) by moving Glirdan upwards in the vote-tally to challenge the real lynchee of the day? What she says about Nilp on day1 is basically sensible (remember: she doesn't know Nilp's playing style - as neither do I), but her overall jumpiness & aggressiviness just confuse me - and "beating the dead Duck" - as someone put it... But she would really have to be extra nervous to run rampant like that, as I know she can be cool and reasonable in times of trouble - well, at least mostly.
So if you lynch Roa, and she turns out to be a duck, look at the "not so well-known players"! It could explain something, if she were the only experienced or otherwise crafty duck - then losing one could call these desperate anxiousnessess about...
I don't know what to make of her. Weird, I say. I might vote for her, but just don't know. If she would be a werecrerature in three games of our (now) five shared ones, that would just be some fate (I've been an innocent in all these)!
Morm
Posted utterly careful posts about Nilp. Suspecting, and then again not suspecting... and in the end voting me at the early stages (hoping to get the innocent lynch on as lifting me to be a reasonable lynchee). But that can be seen as understandable too. The thing that caught my eye, was in his post #105
Quote:
|
I find Sleepy's sudden vote for Nilp as odd. I know the whole 'self-preservation arguement' so don't bother. However notice how it came immediately after he became tied with Nilp. Obviously Nilp is a person that would be easy to get lynched today so it does seem highly suspect to me.
|
There is something I just can't get. And I hope Morm will elaborate on this. Sleepy had just reached his second vote by then (and Nilp had two votes too), and in the end survived with one vote, I can't see any problem in voting for the unknown villager to save one's own neck - at least if you don't have heavy suspicions of that fellows giftedness. So why the suspicion, Morm? Your own voting was safe enough...
Surely looks like an intelligent duck, but also one that makes mistakes... and that's the reaason, I won't be going after him wholeheartedly, just now. I might vote him though, if no better options will come forward.
Lalaith
Gave some preliminary suspicions and distastes of Nilp's playing, but later said, that after pondering is willing to give him another chance. Her vote largened the scope of votees (6th vote, the first for Glirdan), so hard to say.
Not specially duckish - but then again, that might just be the thing: playing like a duck, and not to appear like one...