Just thought I'd update this, if anyone still wants to try this method of reasoning:
The Evil Wizard did pick:
Loki
Naria
Nogrod
Nilp
(hmm... maybe s/he does have a fascination with allteration *coughFeacough*
)
The Evil Wizard did not pick:
The Saucepan Man
the phantom
Celuien
Lhunardawen
Cailín
Firefoot
morm, the list is final for toDay. Tomorrow, it may change quite a bit. Then again it may not change but for one. I won't say for sure until then.