[maikafanawen]

I HAVE NOT READ THE SILM SO MY ANSWER IS NOT VERY COMPLETE.--the caps are for emphasis [img]smilies/biggrin.gif[/img]

I didn't know Goldberry was an elf. Assuming Tarien Ithil is right, then I'd say she would be the fairest of them all only in my opinion, because she was the most peaceful and laid back--my favorite qualities in a person.

From the sounds of it though, Luthien is definitely 'fairest'. For her appearance obviously, but she must have been one tough she-elf to fight for Beren like she did. I'd give her full credit if I knew the whole story!

Then I also liked Arwen bunches in the book. She was very noble. The perfect queen for Elessar. I still shudder whenever Liv Tyler comes on the screen in pointy ears and an imitation gown.

-Maikafanawen

[ June 19, 2003: Message edited by: maikafanawen ]