Okay, now I'll quickly explain the comment I made earlier.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by me
For right now, I'll just say that from the voting alone, Valier looks suspicious. Anguirel, Diamond, and Mac also make votes that would be the logical vote for a WP to make at the time it was cast. Firefoot's too, though a bit less so.
|
Why are their votes Penguinish, you ask?
Here are my reasons for suspecting their votes (in order from most suspicious to least).
1) Valier
She voted for
Anguirel when the voting stood at-
Lalaith-4
Kitanna-3
Boro-2
Roa-1
Ang-1
She cast the vote when there were only three non-voters left. At that point,
Lalaith had not revealed, and so it was a solid bet that, with two people already above him,
Boro was safe, and thus a fellow Penguin's vote was not necessary to save him. A smart penguin would probably not vote for
Lal or
Kit (don't want to be part of lynching an innocent), would not vote for
Boro (too risky to vote for him at that point), and would not vote for someone who had no votes at all (it would look like a throwaway vote).
The perfect scenario would be to vote for a Penguin with only one vote. It would create seperation without much of a risk. Is that what happened? Are
Valier and
Ang Penguins? We'll find out eventually.
2) Anguirel
He cast a very early vote for
Eonwe. That's not a huge risk though, because we have retractable votes. As soon as
Boro received a vote,
Ang switched his vote to
Kitanna, tying her for the early lead with
Lalaith at two votes a piece. Padding
Lalaith's lead would've been a bit too bold for a Penguin, so
Ang did the next best thing and elevated another innocent into the lead.
3) Diamond
When
Boro moved up to two votes with
Kit and just behind
Lal (who had three),
Di stepped in and bumped
Lal back up to a two point lead.
4) Mac
When
Mac steps in it is a decent bet that
Boro is safe (down 4-2 to
Lal), and so
Mac votes for
Kit, bumping her up from 2 to 3. That seems like the sort of thing a Penguin would do. Instead of voting for the leader and getting the hands dirty, or appearing like you're trying to pad the lead to save a fellow penguin, you instead elevate another innocent up to near the top.
5) Firefoot
She was the first to stack her vote onto someone who already had a vote. Also, she never tried to retract despite the fact that she had voted for the Seer. That doesn't sound like
Ff (though I guess it's possible she was just busy).