[Roa_Aoife]

Originally Posted by the phantom

Jenn did her job- she made the village waste a lynch on her as opposed to getting killed by the WPs. Though I guess it's good she's gone, as now no one need wonder if someone is a sneaky Cobbler.

Say what you wantm it's one less thing to worry about. At least it was a suicidal cobbler and not a misleading cobbler.

Do you think both WPs voted for her? Did they suspect she was the Cobbler and tried to keep her alive? Do you think the WPs saw a chance to lynch Jenn over Valier and took it knowing Valier would surely be a likely vote again today? Or do you think Valier is a WP and she was barely saved by the Cobbler?

Well, after Jenny was revealed as the cobbler, I went back and looked at her posts to see if she had tried to hint her status, or if she was trying to protect someone in the same manner she tried to protect Boromir. I smacked myself in the head when I found it.

Originally Posted by Jenny

And as I can see it, a bomb and a...a...nothing do not point to penguins. Those cute little birds couldn't possibly have made a bomb. I don't know anything about pyrotechnics, but I'm sure it requires opposable thumbs, or fingers, or something.

Originally Posted by Jenny

Those poor pretty penguins...I just never expected they might be evil! My dear Phantom (which phantom were you, again?), your extensive knowledge of them frightens me, for I know little about anything.

It's obscure- I didn't even pick up on it till I read the narration of her death, and then I remembered her saying this. It's possible however, that the penguins did pick up on it, especially with behavior towards Boromir, whom she likely suspected to be a penguin.

Boro on...
1) Valier
Is Boro betting on the defending-a-fellow-WP-is-too-obvious-to-be-believable approach, or is he trying to guarantee an innocent Valier's demise if he is discovered?

Even if Boromir wasn't planning to die, such a connection is incredibly obvious. He had to be aware of the possibility of his death, and know that this owuld be looked at later. It seems like an attempt to point a big finger at Valier. From this alone, I would say no.

2) Eonwe
Not as obvious as Valier, but definitely pointing towards innocent, though the statement has a slightly negative ending, and Eonwe seems ignored compared to Valier. What does that mean?

From the quotes alone, it appears he's just coming up with something to say about Eonwe. He was going along with the general consensus that Eonwe was quiet and needed to be around more.

3) Firefoot
For some reason I am still uneasy with Boro's talk about Firefoot. If FF is innocent, kudos to Boro for triggering a false alarm in my head.

Boro is trying to put it into people's heads that Firefoot is someone you want to have around, and yet he feels the need to say that he'd be scared of her as a wolf and that he wouldn't be surprised if she was one. What do people think about that?

This does worry me. He's pointing people away from her, but at the same time distancing himself. It's very... convenient.

4) Naria
What, is Naria playing in this game? Could've fooled me. She's being very quiet and under the radar. She didn't do enough to get a good reaction from Boro.

From his statements alone, he's pointing people away from her. Naria is a werewolf ninja, though, and Boromir is echoing most others' thoughts on this.

5) Enca
Same thing as Naria- Enca hasn't given me enough to be comfortable with her. I'd almost be willing to vote for either of them just to get rid of their silence.

(I say something like that every game, don't I)

Boromir mentioned Enca without saying anything about her. On the other hand, there wasn't anything to say about her.

6) Ang
Boro puts Ang on the most suspicious list, and clearly paints Spawn as the reason why. What is the purpose? If Ang is a WP, then Boro is trying to show his suspicion of him to make himself look good, while at the same time making a statement that shows he will not be voting for him. Or perhaps he is trying to make Spawn look like she is setting up an innocent Ang, which would speak to Spawn's innocence as well.

It seems more like Boromir was jumping onto a good looking case.

7) Spawn
Is Boro's last statement meant to stick in our heads and lead us astray? He has Spawn firmly on his innocent list after finding her fishy early. Is he trying to bring an innocent to his side?

I think he was looking for people to suspect (always a problem as a wolf) and then backed off because he was leaching off her case against Ang.

8) Diamond
So, do you see anything unusual there?

Stating confusion with a certain player- I've done it to innocents as a wolf, I don't see why he wouldn't either. At the same time, he may just be attempting to distance himself.

9) Roa
He mostly argues with Roa, and places her on the most suspicious part of his list, and then later says she's innocent. Is that suspicious? Was Lalaith on the right track or not?

First he doesn't see any significance in my one post, then he uses that same post as a reason for putting me on his most suspected list, then he backs off and says I'm just a misguided innocent. And Ang and Jenny said, "Really, Roa, there's no contradiction at all...." GRRRR! I TOLD YOU SO!

Again, he needed people to be suspicious of. I was an easy target since I was absent. Then, I showed up, called him on it, and he says that maybe I'm just a misguided innocent. Which is funny, because that's the exact same thing I said about Valier when she had me pegged as the EW, and I was afraid her over-reaction would get her lynched and then make people take her seriously.

And Lal was right about one thing- I am devilishly brilliant, and I can pull off looking helpful when guilty. I like to think that I'm helpful when innocent, too, though. I did spot a wolf and a cobbler, after all.

10) Mac
Is Boro trying to cover for his brand new WP buddy? Or is he maybe trying to gain a friend early by extending a hand of trust?

I suspect the ol' "Get the newbie on your side" trick. The idea behind this trick being that the newbie will be grateful that someone in the game believes them, so they don't feel so lost. Mac seems a bit too clever for that though.

Oh, and I just thought I'd say that we shouldn't be too worried if we don't catch a WP today. Considering the population of the village the odds are against us. And really, we've gotten a WP and the Cob so far, so we've got to miss sooner or later.

Just so long as we don't stay off track for long.

Such an optimist....