View Single Post
Old 09-09-2006, 11:42 AM   #200
Boromir88
Laconic Loreman
 
Boromir88's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: USA
Posts: 7,521
Boromir88 is wading through the Dead Marshes.Boromir88 is wading through the Dead Marshes.Boromir88 is wading through the Dead Marshes.Boromir88 is wading through the Dead Marshes.Boromir88 is wading through the Dead Marshes.Boromir88 is wading through the Dead Marshes.
Send a message via AIM to Boromir88 Send a message via MSN to Boromir88
White Tree

"Well everyone, here's a rundown of how I feel about each one of you.' Boromir began. He continued 'Who I feel is innocent and will most likely not vote for them on this day, Nogrod, Mac, Lommy, Valier, and Gil-galad. Who I'm unsure and don't know about Volo, Sleepy Ranger, and Naria. Who I'm suspicious of and who I may vote for today, Kath, Diamond, or Valesse.

'The only new person I've brought up to the group of people I will likely not vote for today is Gil-galad. Gil's family history is filled with the play of not saying a lot, and not making a lot of sense. But, the little that I have heard from him today has made sense, and I don't think we should so easily disregard and ignore what he has said. To me, Gil doesn't say a lot, but that's not what's important, it's what they say and what they do. And so far Gil hasn't done anythng to raise suspicions from me.'

'At the beginning of the day I thought of Naria as more on the innocent side, but have grown just a tad bit wary for her quick jump on Kath's summary, and claiming there was no commentary in it (though she has taken that back). And to answer your inquiry Naria, it was a misreading upon my part.Kath said that in post 158 Nogrod had cleared Mac and myself, and I thought she was suggesting Nogrod, Mac, and I, along with Thinlomien were in league with Menel. In which case I later noticed that it seems Kath did not find Mac as a suspect and one of the one's in league with Menel. And that mainly she believed Nogrod, Lommy, and myself staged this fight with Menel.'

'With Sleepy and Volo I'm leaning a little more on the innocent side, but can't placea finger on them. Volo's done more today, which has cooled some of my uncertainty, but he doesn't have a lynched wolf under his belt yet. As far a Sleepy goes, I'm not somebody who goes after the quieter ones right from the start and I from what he has said, I find nothing overly wolfish about. I certainly hope when you aren't running around in the wild Sleepy that you would have some more time to share some insight with.'

'That means Diamond, Kath, and Valesse are the suspects I'm looking at. I guess I'll start with Kath. Though I did misunderstand part of her summary, and for that I apologize, I still find it wolfish. Perhaps it's just because I'm not a fan of conspiracy theories, and still rather confused about her choreographing thought. I'll leave this question up for you Kath, to ask and think yourself. If I was a wolf, do you believe I would do something so bumbling as staging this act with a fellow wolf and purposefully get him lynched on Day 1? You have the access to my family records, some of my own have regrettably been cursed, but as you'll notice my family have never been one's to like whacked out conspiracy theories, nor the few accounts I have of wolf-members have they been one's to stage fights with fellow wolves on Day 1. Perhaps they attempt this later on in the game, but Day 1, no.'

'Valesse because of their interaction with Menel yesterday. Now yesterday, I'm afraid I didn't get too much out of Menel's posts, as he went after random people and didn't mention everyone. But just the interaction and words of Valesse about Menel gets me a little worried.
Quote:
Menel, on the other branch, is some what bold, a little hasty... though not entirely brash. I do not believe that dice are a means to catching werewolves, but seeing as she has not cast a vote, it could have only been a sick joke in order to get others talking." Frowning even more, Valesse narrowed her giant eyes "And if this was the case, I should hope that your sense of humor improves."
This is a note I have jogged down in my book and made a reference of. Usually wolves don't like to group themselves together, they like to stay seperate as much as possible. But, they like to nudge a little suspicion towards a fellow wolf, without overly committing, it's a way of trying to appear innocent, like 'hey see I suspected him/her and they were a wolf!'. That's what it's designed for. I'm reminded by my great-great-great-great Grandpa's play as a wolf with Lalaith's ancestor who was also a wolf. And he didn't want to get people to overly become suspicious of Lalaith, but would say some things like 'this play looks wierd by her, I'll watch after her, but not going to make too much out of it.' It was designed to be a safe move, and make himself look innocent, as he would be nudging suspicion towards a wolf. And that statement by Valesse reminds me of my 4 times great grandpa's play with wolf-partner Lalaith. It looks like Valesse was doing this same thing, like 'Menel seems a little awkward, but I don't want to make too much out of it.' Just seems like a wolfish play, as I had a wolf ancestor who did the same thing.'

'Finally, Diamond, I just find her actions all around, most specifically in post 186 to be worrying. She goes after Mac's reasonable deductions by just saying she's a rebel and no one tells her what to do. And she seems to be jumping on with others who have found Kath's summary as slightly suspicious.'
__________________
Fenris Penguin
Boromir88 is offline   Reply With Quote