You use good logic
Fordim, but I'm not sure I'm willing to believe the whole concept of Sauron recognizing a Ring-bearer and being able to tell different hobbits apart.
In person, absolutely, you're right. But through the palantir....
Remember, at first Sauron thought he was talking to Saruman. That should be an obvious clue that Sauron couldn't tell a fellow Ring-bearer. I mean, he couldn't tell the difference between Saruman and Pippin!
I think the fact that the palantir was involved changes the situation.
Quote:
|
This is the most labored grammar-based argument I've seen since the last time the the wings debate reared its head.
|
Well, thank you.
