What a delightful little experience that was. That village was so fun that I think there is a good chance that it would have been fun even without my participation.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by SPM
If I did win, it was through no particular effort on my part.
|
Wrong. False. Winning was a feat, for it proves that you were successful at appearing innocent to your fellow villagers. More successful than me even judging by
Mith's vote the final day.
Though I'm a bit peeved at you for lynching me. I'd only ever been lynched once (WW III), and I didn't want it to happen again.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by SPM
In any event, it would appear that both Wolves were dead by the end of Day 2. So I claim a village win.
|
Me too.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by SPM
Btw, phantom, your little ploy wouldn't have worked anyway. I have no intention of casting my final vote until I could be more or less certain that Mithalwen would not be returning.
|
But, could you at least admit that you were slightly outraged by my declaration that my earlier vote wasn't legitimate? I'd been saving that little gem for quite a while, and was itching for a chance to use it. As it got to be later on the final day, it didn't make any sense to me that
Mith was the final WW, and you of course I had believed innocent for quite a while, but your choice to vote for me drew my righteous wrath and so I used my little invalid vote trick on you.
Twas nothing personal. As I said in the game, it was "Simply because you voted for me".
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ang
But when I returned in the morning to find myself hanged, I saw red and started baying at my screen for Sauce's blood...
|
Not my blood, eh? Does that mean I am forgiven,
Ang?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by lmp
I was convinced that the phantom was the final werewolf based on this basic truism: if he gets killed or lynched by the end of Day 3, he's innocent because no werewolf would want to let him live, so dangerous is he. If he lasts and lasts, he's a werewolf, for obvious reasons. Since both of the werewolves were killed by the end of Day 2, the choices were clearly random, and so the phantom survived as long as he did. So the "truism" still holds. I'll be watching you, phantom....
|
Lovely.
Oh, but one game defies the truism. I survived to the end as an innocent in the last WWJ game I played. Of course, it only happened because I falsely claimed to be the Hunter.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by SPM
if you come round to the view that someone is a Wolf, you can always find the material to justify that view, whether they be a Wolf or not
|
Aye, laddie.
Actually, I think it speaks volumes about our instincts the way we were so incredibly indecisive on that final day, and voting with such little conviction, and were unable to shake the thought that we were all three innocent.