View Single Post
Old 12-20-2006, 12:30 PM   #115
Holbytlass
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
 
Holbytlass's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: The Party Tree
Posts: 1,042
Holbytlass has just left Hobbiton.
Mormegil:I don't feel at this time there is a real thing between Rikae and Mormegil, as in they are trying to distance themselves by fighting. Morm's was a real in-character banter and understandably Rikae would react having been singled out. Morm doesn't (that I recall) state why he's glad that Nogrod is under suspicion nor says if he finds Nogrod suspicios or not. I think Morm is grasping at straws when saying he is confident that Valier is a cobbler, either trying to find something substantial to go on for a first dance or trying to get us to go along with him-he did want us to trust him. As stated, not a huge fan of retracting votes even when allowed.

Cailinoesn't seem to want to talk about topics at hand, but after initial funfinger pointing has great points about others in her observations that deserve to be looked at. always her helpful self

Kath:Adds to the differing points that need to be looked at when talking of a strategy-in this case dealing with hiding wolves. Does bring up good point (although right now I disagree-but she's a thinker) of the possible Morm/Rikae bold bluff

Farael:Somewhat contraversial with going after quiet group. I agree and get what he's trying to say. The only thing weird is that he usually goes after someone vehemently even on first day

Rikae:seems to be her usual self, only thing I find funny (as in an interesting way) but not totally suspicious is her being mostly against the quiet group lynching but finds those who have said the least makes her nervous. Again the thing with Morm-both seem natural.

Nogrod:I don't find him particularly suspicious. good points about those who leave little trail .and his thoughts on others

Lalwende:nothing to go on here. her thoughts on others-has a good point of what cobblers might do

Kitanna:adds her opinions to main issue and some dancers, not much to discern

Naria:points out that Rikae could be pulling bold bluff move, only thing that could possibly be seen as suspicious is her extremely defensive manner

Macaulare:I don't see why people think Macs a cobbler

Celuien:her opinions of others don't seem to be off the wall other then being puzzled about Morm's checking the PM's for seership

Valier: not much to go on

Eomer:some thoughts on what a cobbler might do (what he might do?) never says why he's suspicious of Kath, Valier, Naria and Lalwendë

Folwren:I don't find her seeing Fareal's point of dealing with hiding wolves as suspicious

Suspicious
Mormegil for the confident Valier is a cobbler theory
Eomer he's smart enought to pull off a bluff of stating what he is going to do as a cobbler
Naria because of her defensive manner
__________________
Holby is an actual flesh-and-blood person, right? Not, say a sock-puppet of Nilp’s, by any chance? ~Nerwen, WWCIII
Holbytlass is offline   Reply With Quote