The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXVII

Macalaure · 12-26-2006, 01:29 PM

I re-thought Naria's vote.
If she's Celuien's fellow wolf, she would have voted Valier to save her (unless she was very gutsy). It wouldn't have made anybody too suspicious, I think.
If she's Celuien's cobbler, she would have done the same, no doubt.
So, unless she's the other wolf's cobbler (possible, but I have better candidates), she's innocent.

I think Eomer looks very wolvish. He's just as uncontroversial as Celuien was. Would two wolves act exactly the same? I'm not sure. Maybe they trusted on the cobblers to create enough smoke to hide in if they avoid to draw any attention towards them.

Nogrod, I think you make very little sense in your last post. There's somebody else who voted for Celuien who is just as dangerous to the last wolf (probably a lot more) as me and who would have left a lot less trails: mormegil! What you say seems to me like you're purposefully trying to lead the village along the wrong track, Cobrod.

I still think Farael looks very cobblerish, too. Everybody else looks more or less innocent to me but, as you might guess, that might quickly change.

I fear Rikae was just another safe kill (seems to be their strategy), but I'll have another look at what she said.

12-26-2006, 01:29 PM	#224
Macalaure Fading Fëanorion Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: into the flood again Posts: 2,911	I re-thought Naria's vote. If she's Celuien's fellow wolf, she would have voted Valier to save her (unless she was very gutsy). It wouldn't have made anybody too suspicious, I think. If she's Celuien's cobbler, she would have done the same, no doubt. So, unless she's the other wolf's cobbler (possible, but I have better candidates), she's innocent. I think Eomer looks very wolvish. He's just as uncontroversial as Celuien was. Would two wolves act exactly the same? I'm not sure. Maybe they trusted on the cobblers to create enough smoke to hide in if they avoid to draw any attention towards them. Nogrod, I think you make very little sense in your last post. There's somebody else who voted for Celuien who is just as dangerous to the last wolf (probably a lot more) as me and who would have left a lot less trails: mormegil! What you say seems to me like you're purposefully trying to lead the village along the wrong track, Cobrod. I still think Farael looks very cobblerish, too. Everybody else looks more or less innocent to me but, as you might guess, that might quickly change. I fear Rikae was just another safe kill (seems to be their strategy), but I'll have another look at what she said.