[Nogrod]

Morm and Eomer were the two people here I had began to trust somewhat as they acted relaxed enough and had good points (from my point of view eg. suspecting the same people I was suspecting). I'm really sorry they're gone and I had no chance to meddle in the last voting because of my London-friends (RL).

I also must admit that I greatly suspected Naria and Valier. I had some bad memories of those two playing together just a short while ago. And they looked suspicious to me. Obviously they weren't the baddies.

But a few points from yesterDance then.

Originally Posted by morm#251

Naria to top the list, Mac, Farael are the others. Three people singing the same off beat tune with spurious logic as to why I'm guilty. [...] if you take the general feel of those three or four I promise that at least two of the three are in there likely all three.

It's not the first time in this game I agree with him exactly. Now Naria is gone and she was innocent. So that leaves Mac and Farael. Farael has played too bluntly to be a wolf. His vote on morm yesterDance I think particularly telling here. I regard him as a cobbler now if nothing else comes in to the horizon - and thence would not advise to lynch him without better arguments as we need to get the wolf here. But Mac then?

Originally Posted by Eomer#252

Anyway, I noticed in Celuien's post #94 that she makes use of the Funnily enough, Mac does that in post #232 and #239. All when trying to pacify potential adversaries. Desperate to appear friendly? It's something I've seen before and it flushed out a wolf. (Bad memories )

Anyway, I think that point, as trivial as it may seem, is far more substantial than anything Mac has raised against me. Yet I am apparently his top suspect. Of course, as Mac himself admits, there's nothing wolvish about me, and there's nothing I've said that he can point to and say 'Look at that!' But still.

Know what I think, Mac? You're scaremongering. You're eager to whip up an anti-Eomer frenzy because you know how easy it is. When you repeat the assertion that I am very suspicious, but without any semblance of a reason why — other than that I'm supposedly playing like Celuien (?) — it makes me wonder.

Now why would Mac do such a thing as an innocent villager? It doesn't sound like him anyway.

Originally Posted by Cailín#256

Naria is not Celuien's cobbler. Farael might be. He seems to have an air of desperation today. I am also considering him as the possible other wolf, to be honest.

I noted the same desperation there but would disagree with his status still. He's a cobbler. I'm pretty convinced of it. He wouldn't have made such a number of himself and his plan if he were a wolf. I really trust him to be the cobbler (of Celuien). If he is a wolf you should grind me to a mincemeat then... (sorry about another Finnish idiom)

Okay. I changed my mind and will post this before I get to see the rest of it, just to give Mac a chance to answer even these few points. I would hate losing an innocent Mac... but this is all under making... sorry.