[Thinlómien]

- In my eyes Holby seems quite innocent. There is no especial reason for that. She is calm, reasonable and helpful (though sometimes nearly to a lupine extent, but I'm still quite at ease about her) and this

Originally Posted by Holby

I did see that but didn't take it as a clue because I was going to answer Anguriel's question since I had originally asked it on the admin thread, Dancing Spawn beat me to it.

speaks for her innocence. Also, when she was a lovercreature last time I played with her, she was a lot more jumpy and less reasonable.

- I'm not entirely sure what I think about Rune. He's a bit confusing (and maybe confused?), but there's nothing that'd make me suspect him. So seems pretty innocent for now.

- Farael's self-vote made me think him quite innocent. I'm aware that Farael is a bold player, but I don't think he would vote himself, be he a wolf (or gifted, for that matter) after being suspected more than slightly and by numerous villagers. Only an ordo can be that careless of his life, though even that is not (in my opinion) a recommendable attitude.

- Nilp seems pretty innocent too. One could argue that his post was a wolf-hiding-behind-statics -post, but I don't think he seems wolvish. He has a genuine air.

- Menel is very difficult. I have my reasons to consider him innocent and there's no problem with the "overall feel" of him, but he's indeed flip-floppy, and as pointed out, eager to join bandwagons.

- Durelin has been really convincingly innocentish today. She's been helpful and she's had good points. But her yesterday wasn't as innocentish and her "lynch all" post, though a joke it was, was something a wolf would be glad to do, not having to take sides on anything. I'll be watching her to form a clearer picture.

- I don't see Volo particularly suspicious by behaviour, but I'm not sure at all about him. Maybe I'm so delighted of his greatly increased participation that I mix it with him looking innocent? I don't know, he's difficult to analyse. But I think (no offense) that if he was a wolf, he'd be more jumpy. But on the other hand, he has been slightly somewhat jumpy/defensive today... So I don't know what to think of him.

- Boro is difficult too. Lately, when he has been a wolf, he's every single time given me a bad feeling I've not been able to define. In this game, he's not giving me one. (Not that he would give me an innocent feel either.) Should I, based on this, think him innocent? No! Boro is far too dangerous to be overlooked and I'm not any kind of prophet. By reasoning, it is always difficult to tell whether Boro is innocent or guilty, and this time is no exception. I'll be watching him.

- Now, Nogrod. He's a difficult one too. Some of the things he says just sound wrong. Kath does have a good point about him. But he's also reasonable and I like his attitude of pointing out things others don't notice or concentrate on, and "shaking" the village. All this feels quite innocentish too.

- I think I should have voted Kitanna after all. She has failed to answer the accusations directed at her and has focused all her energy today to the Eomer-voters. She hasn't commented on anything else! I think I'm going to really vote for her today, unless there is something more incriminating against someone else today.

- Kath is a bit suspicious. Her yesterday's comment about my post still bugs me a bit. Also, as has been pointed out, she's a bit too eager to attack him. But, she's not overtly suspicious. If you forget those little faults, she seems her normal, calm and helpful self. One must keep in mind she's a dangerous and good player...

- Anguirel is quite worrying too. His Eomer-comment just before the deathline yesterday is certainly odd. There's also another thing. Last night (ww-time) I checked the posts on this thread. He had second most posts (12). I remember him being present, but I don't remember him argumenting/ discussing/ making points very much. That worries me too.

- Lastly Valier. Truth be told I'm annoyed with her tactics. As I said, she could easily be a wolf avoiding to be caught by talking the minimal amount. She fails to convince me of her innocence. Okay, I admit, I might mix her annoying me with her being suspicious... Valier, you're a nice and clever gal, please speak up!

--------------

Originally Posted by Nilp

(Speaking of, are there double-lynchings?)

Nope.

Originally Posted by Rune

I see that I made a mistake, I thought Thorin said he would probably vote Durelin not Durin

As funny as they are, should we give up the names if they create this serious confusions? (Or this good excuses?)

In addition, Nogrod later in-directly agrees with Lommy that the points she made weren't good (post 67), which is technically a defense of himself just done in a way that doesn't make him look defensive.

True. Rather than that fact itself, the thing that worries me most is that by saying that he avoided answering the accusation.

edit: xed with the last three posts