Good points everyone, especially
Lal and
davem.
I agree that the version in Silmarillion is much subtler, and I must say I prefer it to the Shibboleth, though the latter is very interesting with it's moral dilemmas.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lal
Makes you wonder if Galadriel was allowed to have it away with Celebrimbor after she left Celeborn in Middle-earth...
|
I don't have HoME XII here right now, but I just started to think of it... If I recall correctly, it seemed that Indis was much in love with Finwë, but Finwë's feelings weren't as deep as hers. Might this be some effect from that he was previously married with another woman? Or am I just misinterpreting the Shibboleth?