The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - WW XXIX Dor-en-Gaur

Lalwendë · 02-01-2007, 03:04 AM

So far I've not seen Gil doing anything odd today so my vote from last time may change. But once a funny feeling is there, it never goes away entirely, so I will keep watching I think.

Right now I'm suspicious of Durelin's sense of certainty. This is what happened on the first day, suspicions began and then a rollercoaster set in and we ended up lynching an innocent, one who I pointed out was far too 'clearly' suspicious. I will look again I think at the origins of Volo's lynching and see if I can work out who was the instigator. The other thing here is that Durelin suspects Rikae for suspecting Celuien at first - I think she was just making a stab in the dark because she's being analytical today (unlike yesterday when none of us had anything to go on).

One person is slightly weird today and that's Morm. Is he being honest that he's trying a new approach? Or is it because he has a 'special' role? Even though I don't know what he's usually like (verbose I presume) the very fact that he says he has 'changed' is odd. Glad he's more talkative though.

I'm pondering Boro, not as a suspect but for his strategy which is risky. Whether he is a Hunter or not is by the by I think as he has put the seed of that possibility into people's minds; it may bring him protection but as time goes on, if we don't get the wolves it might make the rest of us who manage to stay alive get increasingly suspicious. And if he's not the Hunter and the real Hunter stays alive that long, he or she may start up a lynch mob against Boro as the struggle to live becomes more desperate. Interesting. He's not a suspect yet, but he's certainly an enigma.

Who did this stabbing in the dark thing to poor Celuien? Lommy ruminates on this one. Is it mere accident that she is the first to do it at length? Everyone's shied away from any mention of it til now. Or is Rikae the villager with the golden dagger? Had she felt railroaded into changing her original vote for Celuien after Volo turned out to be innocent? More importantly, is all this trying to work out the golden dagger owner is a big distraction?

02-01-2007, 03:04 AM	#210
Lalwendë A Mere Boggart Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: under the bed Posts: 4,737	So far I've not seen Gil doing anything odd today so my vote from last time may change. But once a funny feeling is there, it never goes away entirely, so I will keep watching I think. Right now I'm suspicious of Durelin's sense of certainty. This is what happened on the first day, suspicions began and then a rollercoaster set in and we ended up lynching an innocent, one who I pointed out was far too 'clearly' suspicious. I will look again I think at the origins of Volo's lynching and see if I can work out who was the instigator. The other thing here is that Durelin suspects Rikae for suspecting Celuien at first - I think she was just making a stab in the dark because she's being analytical today (unlike yesterday when none of us had anything to go on). One person is slightly weird today and that's Morm. Is he being honest that he's trying a new approach? Or is it because he has a 'special' role? Even though I don't know what he's usually like (verbose I presume) the very fact that he says he has 'changed' is odd. Glad he's more talkative though. I'm pondering Boro, not as a suspect but for his strategy which is risky. Whether he is a Hunter or not is by the by I think as he has put the seed of that possibility into people's minds; it may bring him protection but as time goes on, if we don't get the wolves it might make the rest of us who manage to stay alive get increasingly suspicious. And if he's not the Hunter and the real Hunter stays alive that long, he or she may start up a lynch mob against Boro as the struggle to live becomes more desperate. Interesting. He's not a suspect yet, but he's certainly an enigma. Who did this stabbing in the dark thing to poor Celuien? Lommy ruminates on this one. Is it mere accident that she is the first to do it at length? Everyone's shied away from any mention of it til now. Or is Rikae the villager with the golden dagger? Had she felt railroaded into changing her original vote for Celuien after Volo turned out to be innocent? More importantly, is all this trying to work out the golden dagger owner is a big distraction? __________________ Gordon's alive!