The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - WW XXIX Dor-en-Gaur

Lalwendë · 02-01-2007, 07:49 AM

I won't be dissuaded from doing an analysis which is what I enjoy.

Yesterday's Votes
Gil
Durelin, Anguirel (x-ed from Volo), Roa, Me, Mac

Boro
Gil, Kath, Volo

Volo
Mithalwen, Farael, Eomer, Morm, Celuien (x-ed from Naria), Firefoot (x-ed from Boro), Rikae (x-ed from Anguirel)

Dead
Volo - lynched
Mac - slain
Roa - slain
Celuien - stabbed

Mac and Roa were both Gil voters. I think we were all dodgy about the way Volo got set about by the mob too, with Anguirel changing at a late stage. Nobody here seems much in cahoots aside from a feeling that Volo was being so over the top he couldn't possibly be a wolf. Incidentally, there's an interesting game dynamic of those who believe in outright 'honesty' and those who suspect it as bluster.

Volo came in all guns blazing and he was an easy target really. A blameless lynch? I'm not so sure today. There have to have been, statistically speaking, some innocents involved in voting for him. With seven votes, we can take away Celuien leaving six votes. Would all of the wolves go for one lynch? Has that ever happened? There are a fair few names in here that have not as yet raised any suspicions with me. Mithalwen and Morm I have already mentioned as raising doubts for the first time today, and I have been considering Farael but there's nothing much to go on yet. I doubt Eomer would be silly enough to raise this notion if he was a Wolf. Or would he? Bearing in mind I am new to this? Of course Celuien was innocent. That Rikae switched from Anguirel suggests she was swept along as if she had been in this 'camp' she'd just have stuck with Anguirel, him being an enemy. But Firefoot is interesting as she switches from the Volo-lynch-camp rival, Boro. So from this I deduct Mithalwen, Morm, Firefoot as definitely fishy and Farael worth a second look. If Gil is a wolf then we have a list of five there, which narrows the odds.

02-01-2007, 07:49 AM	#236
Lalwendë A Mere Boggart Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: under the bed Posts: 4,737	I won't be dissuaded from doing an analysis which is what I enjoy. Yesterday's Votes Gil Durelin, Anguirel (x-ed from Volo), Roa, Me, Mac Boro Gil, Kath, Volo Volo Mithalwen, Farael, Eomer, Morm, Celuien (x-ed from Naria), Firefoot (x-ed from Boro), Rikae (x-ed from Anguirel) Dead Volo - lynched Mac - slain Roa - slain Celuien - stabbed Mac and Roa were both Gil voters. I think we were all dodgy about the way Volo got set about by the mob too, with Anguirel changing at a late stage. Nobody here seems much in cahoots aside from a feeling that Volo was being so over the top he couldn't possibly be a wolf. Incidentally, there's an interesting game dynamic of those who believe in outright 'honesty' and those who suspect it as bluster. Volo came in all guns blazing and he was an easy target really. A blameless lynch? I'm not so sure today. There have to have been, statistically speaking, some innocents involved in voting for him. With seven votes, we can take away Celuien leaving six votes. Would all of the wolves go for one lynch? Has that ever happened? There are a fair few names in here that have not as yet raised any suspicions with me. Mithalwen and Morm I have already mentioned as raising doubts for the first time today, and I have been considering Farael but there's nothing much to go on yet. I doubt Eomer would be silly enough to raise this notion if he was a Wolf. Or would he? Bearing in mind I am new to this? Of course Celuien was innocent. That Rikae switched from Anguirel suggests she was swept along as if she had been in this 'camp' she'd just have stuck with Anguirel, him being an enemy. But Firefoot is interesting as she switches from the Volo-lynch-camp rival, Boro. So from this I deduct Mithalwen, Morm, Firefoot as definitely fishy and Farael worth a second look. If Gil is a wolf then we have a list of five there, which narrows the odds. __________________ Gordon's alive!