View Single Post
Old 02-01-2007, 10:51 AM   #249
Kath
Everlasting Whiteness
 
Kath's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Perusing the laminated book of dreams
Posts: 4,533
Kath is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.Kath is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.Kath is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.
Send a message via MSN to Kath
Huh, turns out I missed Firefoot off my list of villagers earlier, so my apologies to her. She's on the 'can't get a feel on her' part of the list so I'll be taking a look at her too.

These aren't going to be in depth analyses by the way. I've decided to take a break from doing those because I'm doing far too many of them in RL!

Durelin
Nonsensical first post. Suspicion of Firefoot and Gil, think Volo and Boro innocent. Votes Gil even though she seems more suspicious of Gil. Refuses to protect Boro by lynching Volo since she's not suspicious of him, principles are good I guess. Now seems to be developing some suspicion of Volo, and thinks Rikae and Firefoot are wolves - no reason though.

Rikae
No actual decision over roles of either Mac or Lommy. Bit odd for a first post, most people just shout a suspicion and go. Talks a lot about the roles, but so did everyone at the time. Nothing very concrete, and seems to contradict herself a bit. Could be wolvish nerves showing through. Seems to have calmed down a bit, answering accusation with reason. Thinks Ang suspicious for jumping on the Boro-Cel argument, but then she did it too. Changes vote from Ang to Volo at the last minute as a revenge vote I think. It's sort of a fair point, no one likes to be insulted, but it isn't a great basis for a vote.

Eomer
Says very little. Mentions people as having good thoughts but immediately refutes any idea of trust. Looks at the theories of others, wants Volo lynched. I'm inclined to think this innocent as this is the way he normally plays. Suspicion of Firefoot for much the same reasons as I have. Wants Mac lynched (reasons?!?) and Boro to stay alive. Some mild defence of Volo, quite a flip flop there. Votes Volo (again flips, though apparently this is to protect Boro) and suspects Firefoot and Lommy (not sure where the latter suspicion came from).

Ang
Thinks Boro innocent with reason. Again says Boro is innocent, why keep reiterating it? Talks about what others think, not many original ideas. And again defends Boro. Jumps on Volo for being suspicious, but then, he was. Some ideas coming through now, and votes Volo for what at the time seemed good reason. Tries to get Gil and Firefoot to change their votes (he really was convinced of Boro's innocence, even before the revelation) and says if he can't get Volo lynched he'll move to Mac. Not a fan of that as if you vote for someone you should really believe them guilty and not be so happy to switch. Mentions morm is a little quieter and more bloodthirsty than usual. Guess I wasn't the only one to think so. Looks for Eomer's advice. Thought to change from Volo to Mac but would only do it if Eomer did. Why the 'trust' in Eomer? Considers that Volo and Mac are both wolvish and tries to rat Mac out by getting people to vote Volo. Wrong on both accounts in the end but it was a fair theory. Wandering about all over the place - lynch or no lynch. Actually pretty innocent behaviour. Changes from Volo to Gil after Firefoot votes Volo - bit suspicious as Volo's fate was pretty much sealed by Firefoot so changing meant there was still a good chance Volo would be lynched even if he changed.

Firefoot
First poster though that needn't mean anything. Mentioned Lommy and Mac but that's probably just random Day 1 suspicion. Bit defensive actually, demanding that no one trust anyone. Yes fair point, but the style feels off. Suspicion of Gil and Boro and votes Boro for his words being too 'set up'. I think she's giving Boro too little credit, or trying to set him up herself. Changes from Boro to Volo, says she's not doing this to jump on the bandwagon, but she is so that makes no sense. Tones down the defensiveness and suspects Farael a bit, but makes some very odd points about the Hunter. Says it would be silly for the wolves to leave the Hunter alive, whereas to me it would seem silly if they didn't. If Boro can take a wolf out if they try to kill him they're probably not about to try.

Rune <-- turns out I forgot him too, doing well toDay.
Mentions Mac and Gil. Mention of Mac odd as just carrying on from what others said. Role talk but as I said before, pretty normal right then. Not defensive, answers anything thrown at him calmly. Pretty pessimistic too. In fact he is very calm, is this normal behaviour for Rune? I can't recall. He strikes me as someone who would react more. Is this indicative of some kind of role? Suddenly goes defensive but I think almost out of defeat than anything else as he didn't want to suspect Mac and now, apparently, he must. Some suspicion of Farael for being 'sure', but Farael always is. Votes Mac though there's not much of a reason.

Well, from that I think Durelin and Ang are probably innocent. I was forcing myself to find suspicious things in Ang's posts and though I found some things that probably could be wolvish I don't think he is. Firefoot and Eomer I'm finding quite suspicious as they don't really have reasons for a lot of things which from Firefoot especially does look odd. Rune and Rikae flip flop so much I'm not sure what to make of them.

I'll wait a while on voting. I want to see more of what everyone says, and I still want to keep an eye on morm for a bit. He isn't hitting my radar and it's worrying me.
__________________
“If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.”
Kath is offline   Reply With Quote