[Roa_Aoife]

Manwe voters

Durelin - First vote, put Manwe in the running
Rikae - Second vote, put Manwe in the lead
Hookbill - third vote, had little effect on standings
Legate - fourth, kept Manwe in the running
Nogrod - fifth, tied Manwe with Rikae
Lalaith - sixth, put Manwe in second

Unless someone comes out to contest Rikae's claim, she's a known innocent. And Nogrod I've already analyzed.

Durelin, Day 1

1st post - Says the numbers will make this crazy, thinks it's silly to discuss wolvish behavior, says we need to stir things up a bit more, interested in back and forth between Manwe and SPM, finds Mith strange, thinks her nonchalance is forced, concerned by Glirdan's post, response to Garin

2nd post - thinks Manwe is enganging in "ultimate" Day 1 nonsense, says she has nothing better to go on, votes Manwe, says his "fisherman's wisdom is getting to her/him (?), hopes to be back before deadline, but is uncertain.

(Weak reasoning, but given the ammount of evidence available, and the time limitations, it's understandable)

3rd post - Says the two loudest people (SPM and Nogrod) are getting the most looking at, doesn't like the reasoning of "if they're Faithful, they'd be dangerous," "We've been here before...", doesn't get the case against Nogrod, finds Manwe's reaction interesting, thinks a Faithful would have been more "honey-tongued", doesn't think the timing of Rikae's vote is odd, but rather that is was for Manwe, thinks Garin is Odd looking

(Durelin sure says a lot in one post. I find her statement that SPM was one of the two most looked at players odd. To my knowledge, I was the only one looking at him, though others had disagreed with him. I don't know that anyone said either was being suspected because they could be dangerous if Baddies.)

4th post - thinks her (?) vote for Manwe might stand, but also thinks Rikae and Garin are acting odd, doesn't have enough to go on, even though she doesn't really have alot for Manwe, either, reminds us that a lot of people aren't being looked at at all, agrees with Mith that Roa hasn't gotten a whole lot of notice, response to TGWBS, says Glirdan worries her because he complained about the lack of posting, but did nothing about it, thinks she needs to look at Kath again, think Hookbill brings up a good point, thinks Manwe may be the cobbler, doesn't like Manwe's comment about wanting Nogrod lynched, also bothered by Roa's certainty about SPM, uncertain about going after bold players or quiet players, asks Nogrod for new thoughts

(In her previous post, she said she was no longer certain about Manwe, and here she admits to having no real case, but she seems very content to let her vote stand. All this post has is a lot of waffling about whether or not it's prudent to attack the loud players or not. The fourth paragrapgh can basically be summed up in "The loudest players could be bold innocents, but they could be bold wolves, too." For all her talking, she comes to no conclusions about anything, except that alot of people are acting strange. )

5th post - changes vote from Manwe to Garin

(A vote to save the seer. I can't fault her for that, unless she's trying to make herself look good.)

6th post - Thinks she may have jumped the gun on her vote for Garin

Some odd things from Durelin's posts. Though she says she dislikes waffling, she does an awful lot of it herself, especially in her third and fourth posts. She admits to having no case againast Manwe, but she does very little to find anything, it seems.


Hookbill next.