Gil-galad
1st post - Decides to take things slow, will review and be back later, decides to look at Manwe and Nogrod because they are under the most speculation
(Really playing it safe here- he says he's going after the two most suspicious people at the time, but never comes back with any conclusions.)
2nd post - Says that he also has a tendency not to say much, doesn't think Manwe is a wolf, lists his hunches: SPM, Hookbill, TGWBS, and Rikae
He does not return to vote on Day 1
3rd post - Agrees with Manwe, puts Legate at the bottom of his list, is worried that he won't return, Votes SPM, apologizes
While I, too, think SPM is guilty, I'd like to see more reasoning from Gil. Also, I don't like his apologizing. (I never like it, really. Either you think someone is guilty, or you don't. If you do, have some conviction in your vote. If you don't, then don't vote for them.) However, as he's cited parental trouble in the Admin thread, I'm going to let him slide for now.
Parents can be such a bother, wouldn't you say, Thin?
Kath next!