Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mänwe
Another plus for voting Roa, is, if indeed she is the cobbler then we have eliminated a potential thorn in our side...however if she is innocent (I personally doubt it, I had reservations as Thin did over how 'useful' she was appearing.) Then it would be further proof that Rikae was lying to us. And if she were lying to us, well it would certainly look as if she were a faithful.
Would it not!?
|
Now you're talkin' my fisherman! Even though I would hate to lose an innocent
Roa - I really would - there is sense in this. I mean I first hesitated and was kind of agreeing with
Rikae's suggestion that we do not waste our lynch on her toDay. But there is one problem there and it is as follows.
If we let
Roa live and
Rikae makes it through the Night, we can't say it is because she (Rikae) is a Faithful and has fooled us or because the wolves are bluffing us. And that in turn would mean both that we kill an innocent toDay with some pretty considerable probabilities and that we will be faced with real tough dilemmas toMorrow as to what to do, thus increasing the risk that our gifteds feel the need to reveal themselves...
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Roa
Lynch me and see that I'm innocent, or wait for her to be alive tomorrow.
|
As I said up above: we can't say. It's perfectly possible she's alive toMorrow whether we lynch you or not.
But a truly ingenious piece of work here!
Quote:
|
It occurs to me now, that the wolves may have actually attacked her (assuming she's Tar-Miriel, because it would be a foolish move for a Faithful at this point), not realizing that she was the cobbler in disguise, and the ranger may have truly protected her.
|
I mean this is perfectly possible! But it sure is highly unprobable as well. If
Rikae is a cobbler fighting for her life all
Roa says is possible.
Even though what
Roa says is perfectly possible I would also like to remind us - and myself the most - that bogging down in this issue and not hunting for the Faithfuls would be an excellent masterpiece of Cobblery, the very thing
Roa is here suspected of!
I'll need to take a break from this question now anyhow as my brain hurts...
I'll be doing what I can next to look for any possible villains around here as I'm not having all the time on Day3 (alive, if I am then).
EDIT: X'd with Spm & Brinniel