[Mänwe]

Rikae, I would like to point out I was not the one that made the 'worthless villager' post.

~~~

tgwbs, I see your reasoning here, but do you not think to kill Roa and see what she really is would prove without a doubt whether Rikae was the seer...don't forget by your own reasoning, we will lose the Seer this evening, and so gain no more benefit from her.

Killing Roa and finding out what she is would prove without doubt whether Rikae is the Seer or not. It's a win win situation in a way, for if Rikae is not a Seer than we can kill her, with a certain knowledge she is either the actual Cobbler or Faithful thats if she does not die tonight. If she dies tonight then we have lost her, a possible Seer. But we knew we had lost her when she revealed herself yesterday.

Though there is the chance of one more dream...which if she isn't the Seer proven by whether Rao is the Seer would no doubt just be another lie. I'm starting to think that Roashould be the one to die....

Edited with tgwbs