The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls

Nogrod · 02-28-2007, 01:11 PM

Back again and the game is just getting better!

Good thing Rikae that you remembered that a Cobbler is counted as an innocent in the final counts! I had totally forgotten it. But Durelin also has a point. Especially in a game in a village that might still have some less informed villagers (those who can't bother to read what other people say) in their ranks an informed cobbler could be devastating. tgwbs is right that we can absorb one Cobbler now, but if the going gets tougher - fex. if we don't get some Faithfuls soon - then we'd had much harder situation to get rid of her...

So I must say I'm turning more and more to lynching Roa despite her brave effort. I mean there are some rewards to be gained with it.

And even without any extra-rewards the setting get clearer / lots of information starts to make sense. If Rikae is right which I see more likely then we've gotten rid of a potentially dangerous cobbler from the endgame and not lynched an innocent. If Rikae bluffs and Roa was an innocent, we know she'll be our Cobbler (or possibly although not probably our Faithful) and we can lynch her when we see it fit (if she bluffs I suggest we get the Pan man first).

Also we'll be having a host of other information from toDay to chew toMorrow too.

I'll try to make a summary now but will follow the discussion...

EDIT: X'd with Mänwe & Mith

02-28-2007, 01:11 PM	#7
Nogrod Flame of the Ainulindalë Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Wearing rat's coat, crowskin, crossed staves in a field behaving as the wind behaves Posts: 9,308	Back again and the game is just getting better! Good thing Rikae that you remembered that a Cobbler is counted as an innocent in the final counts! I had totally forgotten it. But Durelin also has a point. Especially in a game in a village that might still have some less informed villagers (those who can't bother to read what other people say) in their ranks an informed cobbler could be devastating. tgwbs is right that we can absorb one Cobbler now, but if the going gets tougher - fex. if we don't get some Faithfuls soon - then we'd had much harder situation to get rid of her... So I must say I'm turning more and more to lynching Roa despite her brave effort. I mean there are some rewards to be gained with it. And even without any extra-rewards the setting get clearer / lots of information starts to make sense. If Rikae is right which I see more likely then we've gotten rid of a potentially dangerous cobbler from the endgame and not lynched an innocent. If Rikae bluffs and Roa was an innocent, we know she'll be our Cobbler (or possibly although not probably our Faithful) and we can lynch her when we see it fit (if she bluffs I suggest we get the Pan man first). Also we'll be having a host of other information from toDay to chew toMorrow too. I'll try to make a summary now but will follow the discussion... EDIT: X'd with Mänwe & Mith __________________ Upon the hearth the fire is red Beneath the roof there is a bed; But not yet weary are our feet...